Housing and Community Development – May 22, 2023
May 22, 2023 at 2:00 PM
- 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Housing and Community Development Committee Recap: May 22, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Housing and Community Development Committee held a remote meeting on May 22, 2023, to address three primary agenda items: the approval of previous minutes, an update on the city’s Affordable Housing Plan, and a policy discussion regarding micro-apartment projects. The committee focused on modernizing housing tools and establishing clearer standards for smaller residential units.
Key Decisions The committee voted to approve the minutes from the April 18, 2023 meeting as presented. Additionally, the committee voted to recommend that the City Council temporarily suspend consideration of Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIGI) applications for micro-apartment projects. This suspension is intended to remain in effect until the broader LUIGI policy is revised to include specific standards for such projects. The recommendation passed with both voting members voting "Aye" and will be forwarded to the City Council.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented an update on the development of a new Affordable Housing Plan, noting that the current plan dates from 2008. The proposed process aims to engage the community, assess current city-funded programs like the LUIGI and Housing Trust Fund, and identify gaps for the next five to ten years. Staff indicated that a Request for Proposals for consultants was released the previous week, with a goal to present the consultant contract to City Council on July 25, 2023, and begin the project in August 2023. Chair Sage Turner commented on the plan, stating, "2008 is a long time ago... I'm confident in our tools, but I think we can always sharpen our tools. So I'm looking forward to this."
The second major discussion concerned the application of the LUIGI policy to micro-apartments, defined as units typically between 250 and 400 square feet. This topic was prompted by a pending application for a project at 46 Aston Street. The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) recommended the suspension of micro-apartment applications to allow for policy revision. Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley questioned the timing, stating, "If we're talking about one developer in particular, it needs to be a conversation with the developer and it needs to be on the agenda... So discussion of this unit as a point of order, is it necessarily appropriate at this time?" Senior Assistant City Attorney Janice clarified that if the council voted to pause consideration, it would affect the project, but the developer could still request an exception to the policy. Chair Sage Turner affirmed the committee's intent to move forward with the motion, noting, "I think that is fair and right and just because they have put in an application that... we have to answer it."
Community Input Two members of the public spoke during the discussion of the micro-apartment policy. One public commenter expressed discomfort with changing policy mid-application, describing it as "changing the rules of the game when you're in the middle of playing it." They requested that the committee clarify the situation with the developer and consider the impact of the delay. In response, Chair Sage Turner stated that the committee would move forward with the suspension motion but suggested the commenter request to be on a future agenda to seek an exception. She stated, "I’m going to suggest that that person that just called request to be on a future agenda... and then we move forward with HCD moving this policy recommendation to council today."
A second public commenter, who is the developer of the 46 Aston project, stated that he was not informed that a previous meeting was canceled and that his project was removed from the agenda. He noted the application has been pending for seven months and argued that the status of his first, unbuilt micro-apartment project is irrelevant to the current application. He stated, "we may not do the project if we don't get the grant," and asked if other micro-apartment projects were in the pipeline, suggesting the review felt like singling out his project. Chair Sage Turner responded by reiterating the vote on the suspension, stating, "I'm generally supportive of this... I don't want this developer to feel singled out. I actually want them to feel protected because a no could be a bad thing." AHAC Co-Chair Margie Bukowski added, "I just wanted the developer to understand that AHEC is reviewing the entire Luigi policy, not just something for micro units... So that he does not need to feel singled out at all."
Follow-ups Staff member Sasha Brutinski, the Affordable Housing Officer, stated she will serve as the project manager for the new Affordable Housing Plan and indicated that staff are currently updating the AHAC pipeline document. Chair Sage Turner explicitly agreed to reach out to the developer after the meeting to ensure everyone is on the same page regarding the timeline.
Impact This meeting marks a significant step in updating the city's housing infrastructure. By initiating the new Affordable Housing Plan, the city aims to better align its funding and programs with current needs over the next decade. The decision to recommend a temporary suspension of micro-apartment grant applications signals a shift toward more rigorous policy standards for smaller housing units, ensuring that future incentives are applied with clear guidelines. The next scheduled HCD meeting is June 20, 2023.
Meeting Video & Transcript