Skip to main content

Housing and Community Development – April 18, 2023

April 18, 2023 at 10:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Apr 4 meetingNext: May 22 meeting
  • 1 h 20 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Housing and Community Development Committee Recap: April 18, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Housing and Community Development Committee met on April 18, 2023, to review several key items regarding city-owned property, housing incentives, and funding recommendations. The committee addressed the approval of previous minutes, the conveyance of a city-owned property to a nonprofit, a request for a land use incentive grant, and recommendations for the 2023–2024 Housing Trust Fund cycle.

Key Decisions and Votes The committee began by approving the minutes from March 29 and April 4, both passing by unanimous roll call votes (3-0). The committee then voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the conveyance of the city-owned property at 3 Hunt Hill Place to KL Training Solutions, the legal entity for the nonprofit "My Daddy Taught Me That," for $1. This recommendation includes deed restrictions limiting the property's use to community development purposes. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend that City Council approve a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) for the Fairhaven Summit project, a 77-unit low-income housing tax credit development in South Asheville.

Regarding the Housing Trust Fund applications, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend that the Redwood Commons, Fairhaven Summit, and Stewart Street Cottages projects move forward as proposed. The committee took a split vote on the Reimagining Deaverview project: Councilwoman Smith and Councilwoman Mosley voted Aye, while Councilman Turner voted Nay, to recommend funding the project as a grant rather than a loan. Finally, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to direct staff to proceed with negotiations with the developer of Oak Hill Cottages to fully develop plans, deal points, and community engagement, with the understanding that the item will return to the committee and Council at a later date.

Discussion Highlights During the discussion of the Hunt Hill conveyance, Kenan Lake, founder of My Daddy Taught Me That, expressed his appreciation for the support, stating, "I just look at this as a win win for the city of Asheville and truly for my daddy taught me that and truly appreciate the support."

The debate on Reimagining Deaverview centered on the distinction between grant and loan funding. Councilwoman Smith argued for the grant, noting, "I see the housing authority as being unique in that really, in my opinion, they are an indispensable partner for us as it relates to all things housing... I believe they are uniquely an indispensable partner for us, not only because of the number of residents that they house in affordable housing, but because of the numerous partnerships that that they have with other developers." In contrast, Councilman Turner expressed concern about setting a precedent, stating, "I am a bit worried about this being different than how we treat all projects. And then I'm also a little concerned that if we do this this way, every phase that comes to us will have to be that way... I'm going to be supportive of staff [who recommended a loan]."

On the Oak Hill Cottages item, developer Barry Bialik raised concerns about the city's 2019 policy on property disposition, stating, "The policy we created in 2019, further limiting the disposition, has not created any properties that have transferred yet... I just want to point out that it's like we've created one of these accredited process, but it might not be working." Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood responded by highlighting the department's strategic priorities, stating, "We are looking at prioritizing for the upcoming fiscal year... revisions to how we assess and ultimately make decisions around city owned land. That's going to be a top priority for the Community and Economic Development Department."

Follow-ups The committee directed that the Hunt Hill conveyance and the Housing Trust Fund recommendations move to City Council for further consideration on April 25. The Fairhaven Summit LUIG recommendation will go to City Council on May 23. Staff agreed to proceed with negotiations with the Oak Hill Cottages developer to refine the plan and engage the community, with the understanding that a future vote will consider the land sale and housing trust fund request together. Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood also stated that the Community and Economic Development Department plans to have robust conversations with the committee and the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee regarding revisions to how the city assesses and makes decisions around city-owned land.

Impact These decisions advance several critical housing and community development initiatives in Asheville. The conveyance of the Hunt Hill property provides a dedicated space for youth development programs, while the LUIG recommendation supports the creation of 77 new low-income housing units. The Housing Trust Fund recommendations allocate resources to five distinct projects, including the Reimagining Deaverview project, which the committee recommended for grant funding despite a split vote. The decision to delay the Oak Hill Cottages vote allows for further negotiation and community engagement, ensuring that the final terms align with the city's evolving policies on land disposition.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches