Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – May 4, 2023
May 4, 2023 at 9:32 AM
- 1 h 57 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) of the City of Asheville met on May 4, 2023, to discuss housing policy, project updates, and legislative tracking. The primary focus of the meeting was the development of a final policy recommendation regarding micro-units and the Leach (LUIGI) incentive program.
The committee engaged in a detailed debate on whether the Leach policy should mandate or merely encourage developers to accept Housing Choice Vouchers. Staff reported that current policy language uses "may," indicating best-faith efforts rather than a strict requirement. During the discussion, staff noted that three private developers they spoke with opposed mandatory voucher set-asides, citing increased barriers to development, while one developer specializing in all-affordable housing supported incentives over mandates. Member Barbara Ann (Babs) Philip expressed that she felt the committee had previously intended to strengthen the language from "may" to "shall" and saw no reason to change that direction. Member Scott Adams argued against singling out one type of housing, stating it lacked objectivity, while Member Tara Irby expressed frustration with questioning policies that create housing given the current cost crisis. Member Andy Barnett noted that nothing had changed except for conversations with developers, who naturally speak in their own best interest.
Following the debate, the committee voted on a motion to amend the micro-unit recommendation. The motion, which was passed unanimously, recommends that the City defer Leach decisions for micro-housing or require developers to fully address the committee’s concerns, including committing to reserving 50% of affordable units for voucher holders. The motion was further amended to require developers to certify that their units meet the housing quality standards of the issuing voucher agency and applicable rental standards. Staff agreed to forward this approved recommendation to the Housing and Community Development Committee.
In addition to the policy debate, the committee received updates on several housing initiatives. Staff reported that the City Council fully approved four Housing Trust Fund applications totaling approximately $5.2M for 281 units, with one additional application on City-owned property currently being developed. Staff also provided an update on the 319 Biltmore Avenue project, noting that the Planning Board deferred approval due to concerns about parking visibility and the project’s urban design; the developer aims to return to Council by the end of June. Furthermore, staff shared a list of state legislative bills being tracked, including House Bill 488, which proposes allowing 3- and 4-unit buildings to be reviewed under residential building code.
A presenter from Aston Flats, David Kloiber, discussed his proposed micro-unit project, noting that 90% of voucher holders in his area lack automobiles, making transit-accessible micro-units viable. He stated his company intends to accept vouchers and work with nonprofits to fill units, and he suggested that voucher acceptance should be a requirement if that is the policy’s intention. The committee also received progress reports from its task forces: the Connect Group reported on community engagement for incentive programs, and the Chair requested members to help recruit new participants for the Build Group task force. Staff noted that the Missing Middle Housing Study working group is in its early stages, with public engagement planned for June.
Staff member Sasha agreed to forward the approved micro-unit recommendation to the Housing and Community Development Committee and to work with colleagues to pull data on voucher usage in existing Leach projects. Additionally, staff confirmed that the CDBG approval is scheduled for City Council on May 9. The committee will consider a presentation from Thrive Asheville on the mechanics of matching voucher holders for a future agenda.
This meeting highlights the ongoing tension between expanding housing supply and ensuring that new developments remain accessible to residents relying on housing vouchers. By recommending a deferral or specific conditions for micro-units, the committee is seeking to balance developer feasibility with the urgent need for affordable, voucher-accepting housing in the city.
Meeting Video & Transcript