Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – April 6, 2023
April 10, 2023 at 9:32 AM
- 2 h 7 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: April 10, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) convened on April 10, 2023, to address governance updates, housing policy debates, and legislative developments. The meeting focused on the election of new officers, a return to a regular meeting schedule, and a detailed examination of how the city’s Luigi tax abatement policy applies to micro-units. Staff also provided updates on funding allocations, state legislation, and the upcoming Request for Proposals (RFP) for an affordable housing plan.
The committee took formal action on administrative matters, beginning with the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting, which passed unanimously after a motion was made and seconded. The committee then elected new leadership following bylaw changes that allow for co-chairs. A motion to appoint Margie Bukowski and Andy Barnett as co-chairs and Brian Methvin as vice chair was made, seconded, and carried unanimously. Regarding the meeting schedule, the committee agreed to revert to its regular Thursday meeting time now that City Council meetings have moved to a virtual format, eliminating previous scheduling conflicts. The chair stated that the time would remain as is for the May 4, 2023, meeting, with the new co-chairs to decide on any future time adjustments in subsequent sessions.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Luigi policy and its application to micro-units. Staff clarified that the immediate charge is to determine how micro-apartments are treated under the existing policy, distinct from the broader affordable housing plan currently in development. Staff reported that in a recent audit of two Luigi projects, one had zero voucher holders while the other had approximately 50%, noting that both were technically in compliance because current policy language only requires developers to "accept" vouchers rather than guaranteeing occupancy. Staff emphasized that communities effective at placing voucher holders in housing can access additional federal funding.
Members debated the necessity of stricter requirements. Brian Methvin argued that micro-units are often commercially viable without subsidy and suggested that if the city subsidizes them, it must require strict commitments to voucher holders, proposing that tax rebates be tied directly to units actually occupied by voucher holders. Margie Bukowski highlighted that the greatest need for vouchers is for one-bedroom apartments, noting waitlist data shows demand for one-bedrooms is more than double that of other unit sizes. Tara Irby pointed out that HUD payment standards are based on bedroom count, not square footage, prompting discussion on whether subsidies should scale based on unit size or value. Chris Day noted that the current "all or nothing" 20-year commitment might not suit smaller landlords, suggesting a shorter-term or annual certification process. David Bartholomew questioned the market data supporting a specific 46-unit micro-apartment project on Aston Street, noting the developer had not specified who would fill the units. The committee agreed to continue working toward a final recommendation on the Micro-Unit Policy by the next meeting on May 4, 2023.
Staff provided several updates on housing initiatives and legislation. They reported that CDBG recommendations will go to City Council on May 9 and that they are preparing to release an RFP for an affordable housing plan in the coming weeks, which may not go to Council until July pending funding decisions. Staff also discussed state legislative activity, expressing concern over a bill making duplexes "by right" in single-family zoning, which would strip the city of local zoning jurisdiction, including tree canopy and steep slope protections, for projects over 10 acres. Additionally, staff noted that the Downtown Association is hosting a presentation by the consultant for the city’s Missing Middle study at the end of the month.
During public comment, a public commenter, identified as a real estate school owner and educator, stated that the meeting was robust and asked if the committee was aware of the Biden administration’s policy on "affirmatively furthering fair housing." The commenter urged the committee to keep an eye on the issue, noting that other states and municipalities are passing their own legislation to protect these standards from being overridden by future presidencies. No members responded to the specific policy question.
Several follow-ups were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff confirmed they are preparing to release the RFP for the affordable housing plan and will send the draft to four volunteers who signed up for it. Staff also agreed to bring the finalized method for community data collection to city staff for review within the next month. A committee member committed to continuing to provide monthly housing data reports, including new land metrics, and offered to train another member with MLS access to ensure continuity. The Board of Realtors reported that they are connecting with community leaders in PVA, Maple Crest, and Hillcrest for evening outreach programs starting April 13, with additional events planned for May, June, and August to cover rental and homeownership assistance.
These discussions matter to residents as they address the critical shortage of affordable housing and the mechanisms the city uses to incentivize development. The committee highlighted a severe lack of buildable land, with one member noting that there is currently only one lot under $100,000 that is immediately buildable in Asheville, while most other affordable lots require developers to pay for infrastructure extensions. With the average sale price of a house reported at $540,000, the committee’s work on tightening voucher enforcement and evaluating micro-unit subsidies aims to ensure that tax incentives result in actual housing access for those with vouchers, rather than just technical compliance.
Meeting Video & Transcript