Noise Advisory Board – April 10, 2023
April 10, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 35 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: April 10, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Noise Advisory Board convened on April 10, 2023, to review operational updates, analyze noise trend data, and discuss the status of ongoing working groups. The primary administrative action taken during the session was the approval of the minutes from the February 2023 meeting. The board also received status reports on vehicular noise initiatives, decibel measurement logistics, and sound exceedance permits, while identifying specific follow-up actions regarding budget requests and data collection protocols.
The board voted to approve the minutes from the February 2023 meeting. A motion was made by Jeffrey Santiago and seconded by Ben Woody, the Assistant City Manager. The motion passed unanimously, with five ayes and zero nays. The meeting was subsequently adjourned without objection. No other formal votes or decisions were recorded during the session.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on the status of the Vehicular Noise Working Group, which is currently in a "holding pattern" while awaiting a decision from City Council on a request to examine ordinance changes regarding vehicle noise. Reb Haizlip noted that the group is "anxiously awaiting" an indication from the Council. Jessica Tomasin, the Chair, shared her personal experience with the issue, stating, "I live on the west side and I've been hearing the same thing. So especially later in the evening, it sounds like people are like drag racing down the street." The Chair also noted that downtown business owners, represented by the Merchants of Downtown Asheville group, are increasingly vocal about vehicle noise and could potentially provide support letters if the issue stalls.
The board also reviewed the logistics for the Decibel Levels Working Group, specifically regarding off-hours noise measurements. Ben Woody clarified that these measurements are strictly for data collection and study purposes, stating, "Let's be very clear from the very beginning. These measurements that we're going to be taking have nothing to do with the ordinance, have nothing to do with enforcement... We are providing you with measurements for you to do your study on the data that you're wanting to collect here." Staff indicated that while the work requires overtime pay, no additional budget is needed, but a signed consent form from property owners is required before entering private property. Rick Freeman, the Vice Chair, responded, "So it doesn't sound like we need funding. We just need to start to make a plan. And the consent thing, that's probably something that we should do first."
Data analysis presented by the Chair highlighted a significant increase in "contact made with alleged noisemakers" and "ongoing investigation and monitoring" in March 2023. Staff explained that these spikes were likely due to the transition to the Asheville App for complaint tracking and the 30-day window required to close cases. The Chair also noted that vehicle noise complaints have increased year-over-year. Additionally, staff confirmed that no new sound exceedance permits have been submitted for 2023, though the venue Rabbit Rabbit is expected to apply for one before their season starts in May. Staff noted that Rabbit Rabbit has historically applied for these permits as a precaution, even if they have not exceeded standard limits.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon by members and staff. Jessica Tomasin and Rick Freeman agreed to email Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley to get an update on the annual report budget requests or confirm her presence at the next meeting. Rick Freeman also agreed to email Jessica Tomasin to coordinate with Nancy Watford from the Urban Forestry Board to gather best practices for getting board recommendations passed by City Council. Ben Woody agreed to send a draft consent form to the board for modification for use in off-hours noise measurements and to ask Daniel, the Noise Administrator, about the spike in "contact with noisemaker" data and whether APD requests have decreased since moving to the Asheville App. Finally, Reb Haizlip requested that the "Adjacent Noise Task Force" be placed on the agenda for the May meeting to discuss sound level limits for residential areas and the use of dBC measurements.
There were no public comments or callers on the line during this meeting. The discussions and follow-ups outlined above reflect the board's current focus on data accuracy, inter-agency coordination, and the pending legislative review of vehicle noise ordinances.
Meeting Video & Transcript