Noise Advisory Board – February 13, 2023
February 13, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 55 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: February 13, 2023
The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board convened on February 13, 2023, to review administrative matters, discuss ongoing working groups, and consider new areas of focus. The meeting included the approval of previous minutes, a review of noise complaint data trends, and discussions regarding legal challenges to current noise ordinances.
Key Decisions The board voted to approve the minutes from the January meeting. Additionally, the Chair proposed skipping the March meeting due to scheduling conflicts for two board members. A motion was made to skip the March meeting and resume in April, which was seconded and approved. The next meeting is tentatively scheduled for April 10, 2023, subject to confirmation of city holiday hours.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented the noise complaint dashboard, noting that it now includes complaint status and codes. A board member remarked that the updated dashboard was "really, really helpful" and made it easier to recognize what the codes actually mean. The board also reviewed updates on existing working groups. The Decibel Levels working group is in the early stages, working with city staff to determine how to conduct surveys at complainants' homes. Regarding Vehicle Noise, Chair Reb Haizlip noted that the recommendation has been sent to City Council but no authorization or direction has been received yet.
The board discussed potential new working groups based on challenges identified by the Department of Public Works. For Commercial/Industrial Abutting Residential, a board member with prior experience in the area offered to lead research into how other jurisdictions handle these issues, noting that most of the research is already done. Regarding Public Space Noise, the Chair proposed a working group to research how other cities distinguish between protected speech, such as street preachers, and nuisance noise, such as buskers. Staff explained that the current ordinance is vague regarding "public space" and "amplification," an issue currently under judicial review in a lawsuit involving protests near Planned Parenthood. The Noise Administrator, Todd Justice, stated that the judge in that case had placed a stay on the city's ability to enforce the ordinance because the city had not adequately defined those terms. He recommended that the board not go "too far down the rabbit hole" with major changes until the court rules. Board member Carmelo Pompilonio agreed, stating, "I think that makes sense... we're kind of powerless until that decision is made at that point." The board agreed to keep the topic on their radar.
Finally, the board reviewed noise trends by year. A board member suggested that future reports include data proportional to population and multifamily housing units to better contextualize complaint increases. Chair Reb Haizlip recommended that the board review the World Health Organization’s guidelines on community noise, stating, "I just think it would be worth reading what the real effect of noise is... It's a comprehensive document on the public health threat of noise. both psychological as well as physiological."
Follow-ups Staff member Todd Justice agreed to find the next court date for the Planned Parenthood noise lawsuit and send the information to board members. Staff member Haley agreed to post the World Health Organization guidelines for community noise to the board’s document file after receiving a link from a board member. Additionally, Haley agreed to double-check city holiday hours to confirm if the office will be open on Easter Monday (April 10) and to notify the board of the confirmed meeting date.
Impact This meeting established the board’s direction for the coming months, including the temporary suspension of the March meeting to allow for continued work on existing and new initiatives. The discussion highlighted the board's intent to better understand the public health impacts of noise through WHO guidelines and to monitor the legal landscape surrounding public space noise enforcement. The transition of digital noise complaints to the Asheville App and the updated dashboard provide the board with more detailed data to inform future recommendations to City Council.
Meeting Video & Transcript