Skip to main content

Planning and Zoning Commission – April 5, 2023

April 5, 2023 at 5:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 1 meetingNext: May 3 meeting
  • 2 h 39 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: April 5, 2023

The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened on April 5, 2023, to review three primary agenda items: two conditional zoning amendments for affordable housing projects and two zoning text amendments. The Commission voted on all four items, approving both housing projects with specific conditions and adopting both text amendments.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Commission approved the conditional zoning amendment for a 77-unit affordable housing project at 3124/3130 Sweet Creek Road by a vote of 3-2. The approval included added conditions requiring the applicant to perform a traffic study, implement recommended mitigations, and work with city staff on a potential crosswalk at the intersection of Sweet Creek and Mills Gap Road.

The Commission approved the conditional zoning request for a 60-unit affordable housing project at 16/18 Restaurant Court by a vote of 4-0. Commissioner Geoffrey Barton was recused from the discussion and vote on this item due to a conflict of interest, a motion that passed unanimously. The approval included a revision to Condition #7, requiring the installation of sharrows (shared lane markings) on the entrance driveway and a good-faith effort to discuss sharrows on Restaurant Court with adjacent owners.

The Commission unanimously (5-0) approved proposed wording amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Chapter 7 regarding open space regulations. This change revises the threshold for building expansions exempt from new open space requirements from 1,500 square feet to 50% of the pre-expansion floor area. Additionally, the Commission unanimously (5-0) approved amendments to allow cat cafés in all commercial districts that permit eating and drinking establishments, expanding the permitted use beyond the Central Business District (CBD). Both text amendments will go to City Council for a vote on April 25.

Discussion Highlights

Discussion on the Sweet Creek Road project focused on traffic impacts, the lack of sidewalks, steep slope constraints, and the height of retaining walls. Regarding the Restaurant Court project, the debate centered on parking ratios, bike storage, lighting, and neighborhood impacts. One member emphasized the necessity of affordable housing in all areas, stating, "Every single neighborhood in Asheville needs to have affordable housing... any neighborhood that comes up and says they don't want it, I will say it right now, I am not gonna listen to that."

On the cat café amendment, a member questioned why cat cafés could serve food while dog bars cannot, noting the distinction in health codes. Another member suggested that since health and agriculture regulations already govern the operation, zoning may not be the appropriate tool for further regulation, stating, "It strikes me as strange that we are regulating this through zoning. I frankly don't think that zoning is the appropriate place when there are, you know, Health Department, Department of Agriculture, other regulations types of businesses have to comply with." Despite this, the member agreed that expanding the permitted use was reasonable. Regarding the open space amendment, a member expressed concern about larger sites, noting, "I just I know that that's going to it's not going to get any easier... i am thinking about these larger ones like yeah what if somebody does have a 30 or 40 000 square foot building they can add on a sizable chunk and not really have to upgrade and we may be continued to be stuck for another 40 years with a 1950s era parking lot and that just seems bad."

Community Input

Public commenters raised several concerns regarding the housing projects. For the Sweet Creek Road project, a public commenter expressed concern that the road is consistently busy and has not been widened despite promises made seven years ago. They argued that adding 77 units without a transportation study is problematic, noting that residents of affordable housing often lack cars and need safe walking access to bus stops and local businesses. They requested that a transportation study be required to mitigate traffic impacts, stating, "It's like 77 units here. The last one was 77 units. It's easy to get away with no transportation study but there has to be a transportation study done at some point because it's getting tripped every single time." In response, a member acknowledged the traffic concerns and suggested that a traffic study could be added as a condition. Another member noted that adding a condition for a traffic study and implementing its recommendations was a reasonable response to community concerns. Another public commenter expressed dislike for the proposed 38-foot retaining walls, suggesting that redesigning the site to use shorter walls (20-25 feet) would be better. A member suggested adding kudzu to the retaining walls to soften the appearance, and the applicant confirmed that kudzu would be planted on the walls.

For the Restaurant Court project, a public commenter (a resident of Bowcatcher Road) raised concerns about the impact of the new development on the neighborhood. They cited issues with an adjacent Section 8 property, including non-compliant tree removal and management issues, and expressed worry about the intensity of 120-150 residents on a small lot with limited green space. They also raised safety concerns regarding the proximity to a methadone clinic and the lack of street lighting on Restaurant Court. In response, a member pushed back on the argument that neighborhoods should be exempt from affordable housing, stating that every neighborhood needs affordable housing and that management issues with one property should not preclude others. They noted that the Commission cannot enforce management practices but encouraged residents to contact the appropriate city departments for complaints. Another public commenter asked if the developer had considered offering bus passes as an amenity for residents, given the location on a bus line. A member stated that while bus passes are sometimes conditions for commercial projects, they have not typically been used for housing developments, but they would bring the idea up with the development team. A third public commenter suggested adding bike lockers similar to those in the county parking deck, noting that residents with small apartments may not have space to store bikes indoors. A member reiterated the need for bike storage solutions and discussed the addition of sharrows.

Regarding the cat café amendment, a public commenter representing a cat rescue clarified that North Carolina regulations require cats to be in a separate area from food preparation and serving. They stated that their cats are fully vetted and quarantined before entering the café, and that the Department of Agriculture has approved their plan. They argued that limiting cat cafés to the CBD prohibits small business growth in other areas.

Follow-ups

The applicant for the Sweet Creek Road project agreed to perform a traffic study and implement any recommended mitigations as a condition of approval. The applicant also agreed to work with city transportation staff and DOT to explore the feasibility of a crosswalk at the intersection of Sweet Creek and Mills Gap Road. For the Restaurant Court project, the applicant agreed to install sharrows on the entrance driveway and make a good-faith effort to discuss sharrows on Restaurant Court with adjacent property owners. The applicant also stated they would provide wall packs and parking lot lighting that would spill over the site, addressing safety concerns. A member stated they would bring up the idea of offering bus passes with the development team for the Restaurant Court project.

Impact

These decisions result in the approval of two new affordable housing developments in Asheville, one in the Sweet Creek area and one in the Restaurant Court area, subject to the conditions outlined above. The zoning text amendments, once approved by City Council, will change how open space is calculated for building expansions and will allow cat cafés to operate in more commercial districts across the city.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches