Planning and Zoning Commission – March 1, 2023
March 1, 2023 at 5:01 PM
- 1 h 35 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: March 1, 2023
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission met on March 1, 2023, to address two primary agenda items: the approval of previous meeting minutes and the review of a conditional zoning request. The Commission also considered a proposal to amend zoning text regarding community notification requirements.
Key Decisions The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the February 1, 2023 meeting. Regarding the conditional zoning request for 283 Merriman Avenue, a motion to approve the request failed with a vote of 6-1, with one member voting in favor and six voting against. Chair Geoffrey Barton noted that while this represents the Commission’s recommendation, the applicant may still proceed to City Council. For the proposed Zoning Text Amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Chapter 7, a motion was made to continue the item to the next meeting on April 5, 2023, to allow staff time to explore revisions. This motion passed.
Discussion Highlights During the discussion of the 283 Merriman Avenue request, which seeks to rezone a portion of the property from Residential Multifamily Medium Density (RM8) to Institutional Conditional Zone (ICZ), several members expressed concerns about removing residential zoning. Chair Geoffrey Barton stated, "I have a really hard time taking away residential zoning from parcels that I feel like... the community wishes to see residentially zoned. That is my position... I will not be the one putting forth any kind of motions [in favor]." Commissioner Jenifer Bubenik questioned whether the Commission should be providing comfort levels without a site plan, stating, "I think absent a site plan kind of showing... we're kind of being asked to do something in advance of that." Commissioner Kimberly Levi emphasized the need for clarity on the project's scope, noting, "I think you need a plan, and you need to know what's going in there so you can tell me why you need that many parking spots... We need to know exactly where you're going there because we represent what's going on in Asheville."
Regarding the Zoning Text Amendment, which proposes increasing the notification radius for pre-application community meetings from 200 to 400 feet and extending the notification period from 10 to 14 days, staff member Chris Collins expressed caution about the city notification standards. Collins stated, "We were really focused on the neighborhood... [regarding the city notification radius] I would be more comfortable with staff putting that in front of you again instead of just rolling with it." Commissioner Brenton Faircloth supported the general goal of formalizing notifications but raised questions about the specifics, saying, "I'm in favor of codifying and formalizing neighborhood meeting notifications. I just think that it's not... we've identified a couple of things... I wonder if we've gotten it completely right."
Community Input Public comment was recorded for the 283 Merriman Avenue item. A public commenter, identified as a realtor, argued that the RM8 zoning should be retained to preserve residential character and questioned the necessity of the rezoning by calculating that existing parking spaces were sufficient. Another public commenter, a local business owner, expressed suspicion that the rezoning might be a step toward an undisclosed development plan. In response to these comments, Chair Geoffrey Barton stated, "I don't speculate when people come in on anything," and reiterated his personal opposition to removing residential zoning. A representative for the seller/buyer spoke in support of the rezoning, clarifying that the conditional zoning limits the parking lot to parking only and restricts the small residential building to compatible uses. The Chair clarified the conditions, stating, "The parking lot has to remain a parking lot. According to that conditional zoning." No public comments were recorded for the Zoning Text Amendment item.
Follow-ups Staff member Chris Collins agreed to explore revisions to the UDO sections regarding city notification of projects to ensure consistency with the new neighborhood meeting requirements. This item will be brought back to the Commission at the April 5, 2023 meeting.
Impact The rejection of the conditional zoning request for 283 Merriman Avenue means the Commission does not recommend changing the zoning for that specific parcel at this time, though the applicant retains the right to take the matter to City Council, which is scheduled for review on March 28, 2023. The decision to continue the Zoning Text Amendment allows staff to refine the proposed changes to community notification standards before the Commission votes on the final language, ensuring that the rules for informing neighbors about major projects are consistent and well-considered.
Meeting Video & Transcript