Design Review Committee – March 23, 2023
March 23, 2023 at 12:30 PM
- 1 h 43 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Design Review Committee Recap: March 23, 2023
The Design Review Committee convened on March 23, 2023, for a special informal meeting to review the conceptual master plan for Project Aspire, a proposed large-scale mixed-use development in downtown Asheville. The project, led by the Furman Company, involves the redevelopment of three properties adjacent to the First Baptist Church, including the site of the former Line and Employee Credit Union Bank. This session was strictly informational; no formal votes were taken, and no decisions were made. The purpose of the meeting was to gather feedback from committee members and city staff to help the applicants refine their plans before a formal review process begins in one to two years.
A primary focus of the discussion was the design of the intersection at Charlotte and College Street. Committee member Michael McDonough described the current intersection as "suburban," "too wide," and the "weakest corner" of the area, urging staff to explore tightening the intersection and improving bike infrastructure. Staff member Lucy Crown, Transportation Planning Manager, expressed concern that bike facilities are currently non-existent in that area and stated that the city would "take a look at" the intersection and the need to fortify bike infrastructure. Committee member Bryan Moffitt also noted that the site currently feels "walled off" and "monastery-like," emphasizing that the corner serves as a gateway to downtown and needs to "pop" at the pedestrian level rather than appearing like a parking deck.
The committee also discussed the design along Central Avenue, which Christina Roush identified as a key gateway to residential neighborhoods and a route for families and bikers. She suggested adding stairs or an opening to the plaza to encourage pedestrian entry into the project. In response to questions from staff regarding sidewalk widths, the project team explained that the current 10-foot sidewalks are due to "build-to-line" requirements but acknowledged that wider sidewalks of 12 feet or more would be preferred if setbacks allowed. Staff confirmed that wider sidewalks and setbacks can be addressed through the conditional zoning process.
Infrastructure and stormwater management were central to the debate, with staff encouraging the use of green roofs and green stormwater infrastructure to manage heat and water quality, noting that these features could serve as functional infrastructure rather than just aesthetics. The project team agreed to explore these options as the design matures. Additionally, Bryan Moffitt advised the team that green roofs are likely to be required for projects of this scale under future code discussions, stating, "You're going to have to do green roofs. That was not a suggestion."
Regarding building use, the project team presented a shift in programming for "Building One" from office space to multifamily residential, citing current office market conditions. This change would wrap around the parking structure and activate the corner of Charlotte and College Street. The team also noted that the hotel building was changed from mixed-use to single-use due to market conditions, with residential units shifting to other parts of the site. Committee members discussed the balance between office and residential space, with Christina Roush and Jeremy Goldstein arguing for the need to maintain a stable employment base through larger companies, while Michael McDonough expressed a preference for smaller local businesses.
No members of the public spoke during this meeting. The project team agreed to incorporate feedback regarding the Charlotte/College corner activation, wider sidewalks on Central Avenue, and green stormwater infrastructure into their revised master plan before resubmission for formal review. City staff in Transportation Planning stated they would review the Charlotte/College intersection and bike infrastructure needs, while Planning and Urban Design staff confirmed that sidewalk and setback adjustments can be handled through the conditional zoning process.
Meeting Video & Transcript