Skip to main content

Design Review Committee – April 20, 2023

April 20, 2023 at 12:18 PM

  • 2 h 56 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: April 20, 2023

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee convened on April 20, 2023, to conduct design reviews for two projects and handle administrative business. The meeting began with the approval of previous minutes and the election of new leadership via voice vote, with Jeremy Goldstein elected as Chair and Christina Roush (Formerly Booher) elected as Vice Chair. The committee then proceeded to review an eight-story mixed-use hotel on Carter Street and a Level Two project at 226 Hilliard Street, concluding the meeting with a unanimous motion to adjourn.

The primary focus of the meeting was the formal design review of the Carter Street Mixed-Use Tribute Hotel, an eight-story building proposed for a former parking lot at 68 Carter Street. The project includes 115 hotel rooms, 24 residential units, commercial space, and underground parking. Staff initially recommended approval, noting the design aligned with Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) requirements. However, the committee engaged in significant debate regarding the site’s compliance with minimum standards versus community expectations, specifically citing a lack of creative stormwater management, minimal streetscape design, and the narrowness of the adjacent streets.

Discussion regarding the Carter Street project centered on several key areas, including the "blank" appearance of the north and south facades and the need for a more distinct design on the Ann Street frontage. The committee also addressed public safety concerns related to the proximity of the AHOPE Day Center (Homeward Bound) and the presence of unhoused individuals. Chair Jeremy Goldstein emphasized that the committee cannot force a private owner to redesign based on the presence of a public amenity, stating, "We can't let the actions of one business' clients dictate poor planning and poor public amenities... The law needs to be enforced... I think the good design element shouldn't be left off for fear that our public municipality is not enforcing the law." Member Steven Lee Johnson expressed regret that the site design was meeting only bare minimum requirements, noting that citizens "deserve more than bare minimum."

The committee also discussed the potential designation of Carter Street as a "Key Pedestrian Street," which would trigger higher fenestration requirements of 70% compared to the current 50% threshold. Vice Chair Christina Roush (Formerly Booher) noted that the current design likely does not meet the 70% requirement, particularly regarding garage doors. In response to these concerns, the committee voted unanimously to continue the hearing to the May 19, 2023 meeting to allow the applicant time to address design concerns related to stormwater, streetscape, and facade articulation. Chair Jeremy Goldstein stated, "My sense is this project will get approved if some of these changes are incorporated into it. And that is our goal is to try to help you make the project better and to approve it and to get you through without having to go to city council."

The second agenda item was an informal design review of a Level Two project at 226 Hilliard Street, known as "The Duke." The committee provided feedback on the building’s massing, materials, and the integration of the new structure with the adjacent existing building. Specific concerns were raised about the "floating" appearance of vertical elements, a lack of connection to the ground, and the complexity of the design. One committee member commented, "My feeling is you broke it up too much. I think there's just too much going on. I would create some bigger chunks." Another member noted, "The building doesn't seem to know that it's got a transparent podium." No formal vote was taken on this item.

Regarding follow-ups, the applicant representatives for the Carter Street project agreed to discuss increasing street trees and exploring permeable paving with their client. The architect agreed to continue developing the Ann Street facade to make it more distinct and to look at adding more fenestration to the south facade where building code allows. The applicant also committed to providing more information on elevations, pool humidity deck details, rooftop restaurant areas, and plantings, and agreed to delay their Planning and Zoning schedule to allow time for these improvements. For the 226 Hilliard project, the design team acknowledged feedback regarding the "floating" vertical elements and stated they would revise the design to better ground the structure and address courtyard activation. Staff noted a meeting scheduled for the following Monday to discuss the SEPTAD (Security) review with the Carter Street applicant.

This meeting highlights the committee’s role in balancing code compliance with the quality of the public realm in a dense urban environment. The decision to continue the Carter Street hearing indicates that while the project meets minimum legal requirements, the committee views further refinement of the streetscape and facades as necessary before final approval. The feedback on the 226 Hilliard project serves as a guide for the design team to improve the building's integration with its surroundings and ground-level activation.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches