Boards & Commissions Committee – March 14, 2023
March 14, 2023 at 9:00 AM
- 25 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On March 14, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee convened to review board vacancies and consider structural changes to the appointment process. Councilwoman Kim Roney chaired the meeting, filling in for Vice Mayor Kilgore. The agenda focused on two primary areas: specific recommendations for several city boards and a staff proposal to shift the appointment cycle from monthly to quarterly.
Key Decisions and Votes
The committee took several actions regarding board appointments and administrative processes. First, the minutes from the February 14, 2023 meeting were approved unanimously (2-0). Regarding specific board vacancies, the committee voted unanimously (2-0) to recommend Joseph Hackett for the Asheville Area Riverfront Redevelopment Commission. Similarly, the committee voted unanimously (2-0) to recommend Debbie Evenchik, a retired CPA, for one of the two open CPA seats on the Audit Committee. For the Multimodal Transportation Commission, the committee voted unanimously (2-0) to recommend Elise Marder for the bike and pedestrian interest seat.
The committee also voted unanimously (2-0) to support a staff proposal to change the appointment cycle from monthly to four or five times per year. Staff noted that this decision is made by the committee and does not require a full council vote. However, no recommendation was made for the Downtown Commission; a motion to recommend only one of the two candidates failed for lack of a second, and the item was deferred to the full council. Additionally, no appointment was made for the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC), as staff recommended holding the vacancy while the board works on its transition plan.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the quarterly appointments proposal, Councilwoman Roney stated she was prepared to support the change, describing it as a "step in the right direction" regarding intentional outreach and equity efforts. She noted, "I know we're getting some feedback around concern about the equity and inclusion and the demographics of who's able to have a seat at the table... I do think when it comes to making that intentional effort around outreach, this is a step in the right direction." Assistant City Manager Ben Woody responded to questions about meeting frequency by stating, "I think that's a great possibility... we would cancel if there is no agenda items."
Regarding the Downtown Commission, Councilwoman Roney explained her hesitation to recommend both business owners, noting, "I noticed that Bill Cooney's application has extensive planning, infrastructure cost assessment, public engagement experience that seems to be meeting some of the skill loss of previous and current appointees." Councilmember Mosley deferred voting on the Downtown Commission until Vice Mayor Kilgore returned.
Community Input
There were no public comments or callers in the queue during the meeting. Councilwoman Roney thanked those who had submitted comments via email, noting that these are part of the public record.
Follow-ups
Staff committed to sending out a vacancy flyer on March 15, 2023, to advertise for the April and summer cycle vacancies, contingent on the support of the quarterly proposal. Staff indicated they will continue to hold the regular monthly meeting slot for the time being to accommodate any emergency appointments or ordinance changes, but they will cancel the meeting in advance if there are no agenda items. Additionally, staff plans to offer training cohorts in February, July, and November, with July potentially serving as a pilot orientation for new members. Staff stated they hope to return in approximately one year, after four cycles, to measure the impact of the new schedule, including application numbers and training attendance, to determine if the change should be permanent.
Impact
This meeting resulted in the recommendation of three specific individuals for city board seats and the adoption of a new quarterly appointment cycle. The shift to quarterly appointments is intended to increase staff efficiency, allow for more robust application review, and expand targeted outreach for diverse representation. The deferral of the Downtown Commission item means that decision will be made by the full council, while the HIAC vacancy remains open pending the board's transition plan.
Meeting Video & Transcript