Boards & Commissions – February 14, 2023
February 14, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 43 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On February 14, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee convened to review advisory board appointments, discuss structural changes to the appointment process, and address ongoing operational updates. The meeting was chaired by Vice Mayor Kilgore.
Key Decisions
The committee began by unanimously approving the minutes from the January 10, 2023 meeting. Regarding board appointments, the committee took several actions:
- Asheville Area Riverfront Development Commission: The committee unanimously voted to appoint Joe Fulmer to the business owner seat. The second appointment (district business/property owner) was postponed to allow for additional applications.
- Design Review Committee: The committee unanimously voted to appoint Michael McDonald.
- Neighborhood Advisory Committee: The committee unanimously voted to appoint Michael Fulbright and Jake Smith.
- Sustainability Advisory Committee (SACI): The committee unanimously voted to recommend accepting changes to make SACI appointments "at-large" and to shorten the committee’s name to "Sustainability Advisory Committee."
For other boards, no formal votes were taken. The committee discussed extending the application period for the Downtown Commission, noting that no motion was required for the extension itself, only for specific appointments. The appointment for the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee was postponed to keep the application process open for additional candidates. No recommendations were received for the Multimodal Transportation Committee, so no action was taken.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting focused on a proposal by Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross to shift from monthly to quarterly board appointments. Gross presented data indicating that 79% of surveyed board members would benefit from additional training, noting that the current training structure is inconsistent across boards. Vice Mayor Kilgore expressed hope for the quarterly process, stating it would allow the committee more time to properly vet candidates and communicate expectations to them. Councilwoman Kim Bruni added that the change offers an opportunity to emphasize that the council is "all in" on board participation and to build community among board chairs.
The committee also reviewed a presentation by Tim Orman, Chairman of the Sustainability Advisory Committee, regarding the proposed resolution to change appointments to at-large seats. Orman emphasized the desire to build on past successes and connect with other ongoing efforts, particularly regarding stormwater, rather than working in a silo.
Additionally, the committee received updates on the submission of annual reports by boards and commissions and the ongoing realignment working group, which includes a survey of board and commission members.
Follow-Ups
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting:
- Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross agreed to look into whether there are three vacancies on the Design Review Committee.
- Councilwoman Kim Bruni committed to following up with Elise regarding the logistics of serving on both the Neighborhood Advisory Committee and the Multimodal Transportation Committee.
- Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross stated that the committee hopes to bring the quarterly appointment proposal back for a vote of support at the March meeting, incorporating feedback from board chairs and stakeholders in the interim.
- Councilwoman Kim Bruni requested a list of the outreach methods and specific monthly publishing dates used by staff to ensure notices are published before deadlines.
- Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross indicated that the clerk’s office work plan includes bringing forward rules and procedures for boards and commissions to clarify processes, such as removing members for lack of attendance. Vice Mayor Kilgore agreed that the Boards and Commissions Committee should look into this to ensure the process comes from the committee rather than individual boards.
Impact
These decisions and discussions aim to streamline the governance of the city’s advisory boards. By moving toward quarterly appointments, the city intends to improve the vetting process and provide more consistent training for board members, addressing the inconsistency highlighted in recent surveys. The changes to the Sustainability Advisory Committee’s structure and name are designed to better align its work with other city initiatives. These steps are part of a broader effort to enhance the effectiveness and participation of the city’s advisory bodies.
Meeting Video & Transcript