Urban Forestry Commission – March 7, 2023
March 7, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 7 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: March 7, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission convened on March 7, 2023, to address operational updates, policy developments, and specific development projects. The agenda included a review of alternative compliance requests, staff reports on urban forestry initiatives, working group updates on budget and policy, and a detailed discussion regarding the Aspire Development project.
Key Decisions The Commission took several formal actions during the meeting. A motion was made and seconded to add the Aspire Development project to the new business agenda; this motion passed unanimously with 7 ayes. The Commission also approved the minutes from the previous month, with the motion passing unanimously with 7 ayes. Additionally, the Commission voted to approve an alternative compliance request for a multifamily adaptive reuse project at 88 West Chestnut Street, which involves eliminating a fence in favor of plant materials to modify property line buffer requirements. This vote also passed unanimously with 7 ayes. Regarding the Aspire Development, the Chair stated that the item would remain on the agenda to be revisited as the project progresses, but no formal vote was taken on the development itself.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the Aspire Development, a conditional zoning application for the 10.5-acre former First Baptist Church site. Commission members expressed concern over the lack of specific tree preservation details in the conceptual plan. Sharon Summerall noted that she had never seen a project come through like this and wanted to know if street trees, specifically well-planted Pin Oaks on Charlotte Street, would be saved. Another member emphasized the importance of early arborist involvement, stating that they are most effective at tree preservation if started before the house is even sited. There was also a focus on tree quality, with a member remarking that if existing trees will not survive the work, the replacement species must be larger than two inches in caliper to provide adequate long-term canopy value. Staff noted that the project is large and more conceptual than typical, focusing on massing.
Other discussions included the introduction of Keith Aiken, who is set to start as the City’s Urban Forester on March 20. Aiken expressed excitement about serving the city in this new capacity. Council member Kim Roney reported that there appears to be a majority in support of funding an Urban Forestry Master Plan. Staff also discussed using Google’s Environmental Insights Explorer data for low-cost, frequent canopy cover updates, with Chris Collins noting that the cost would be extremely low, requiring only staff analysis time.
Community Input A public commenter raised concerns via email regarding the Asheville Municipal Golf Course project, citing the removal of unmarked trees, pruning that may harm tree health, and the absence of a primary arborist on-site. In response, a Council member stated that they had received the comment and would seek an update on the current status of the project to share with the Commission and the full Council. During the discussion, a staff member from Public Works explained that while ribbons marking trees were sometimes ripped off by the public, the project manager was aware of which trees were to be removed. Another staff member from Development Services clarified that while the city has stop-work order authority for private development, enforcement pathways for public projects differ and often involve state regulations or internal management.
Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon by members and staff. Staff agreed to work with the Commission to define the Urban Forester’s role in coordination with Public Works, Parks & Rec, and the Technical Review Committee. Keith Aiken stated that completing an inventory of all street trees is a priority to ensure accurate information on species and age. The working group consisting of Zoe Hoyle, Karen Macneil, and the Chair agreed to refine the fee-in-lieu framework document over the next month and bring a final recommendation to the next meeting. The Chair agreed to compile a list of specific questions from Commission members regarding the golf course, including accountability, pruning, soil compaction, and arborist presence, to send to the project manager, Chris Corral. Staff and the Commission agreed to request that developers provide specific details on which existing trees will be saved and how they will be protected ahead of the March 23 Downtown Review Committee meeting. Additionally, Chris Collins agreed to continue analyzing raw data from Google’s Environmental Insights Explorer to determine its accuracy and utility for future canopy reporting. Staff also agreed to look into improving communication protocols between city staff and residents regarding complaint resolution.
Impact These discussions highlight the Commission's focus on balancing development with long-term tree canopy health and community engagement. The decision to keep the Aspire Development on the agenda ensures ongoing monitoring of tree preservation efforts for a significant downtown project. The introduction of a dedicated Urban Forester and the exploration of low-cost canopy data tools aim to improve the accuracy and frequency of urban forestry reporting. Furthermore, the commitment to refine the fee-in-lieu framework and improve communication channels addresses concerns about how the city manages tree-related funds and interacts with residents regarding project impacts.
Meeting Video & Transcript