Urban Forestry Commission – April 4, 2023
April 4, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 59 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: April 4, 2023
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on April 4, 2023, to address a range of urban forestry issues, including development compliance, budget advocacy, and the status of a major golf course project. The meeting began with the unanimous approval of the minutes from the previous session. The commission then reviewed a request for alternative compliance for a development at 234 Broadway, which sought to reduce the rear property line buffer and utilize silva cells for street trees due to site constraints. After discussion, the commission voted 4-2 to accept the alternative compliance request.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the golf course project, where staff provided updates on the completion of tree removal and pruning. Staff reported that the tree portion of the project is complete and confirmed that the city arborist was present on pruning days. However, staff acknowledged that two trees not on the removal list were taken down, both of which had broken in a storm, and noted that brush clearing was a separate pursuit by the golf management company. Staff also indicated they would review areas where the contractor parked on tree roots to determine if remediation is needed.
The commission discussed strategies to advocate for urban forestry funding, including a tree inventory and master plan, ahead of the City Council budget vote. Members debated the approach, with some suggesting a direct contrast to baseball stadium funding, while others argued for focusing solely on the necessity of the urban forestry program. The commission also reviewed the newly adopted Municipal Climate Action Plan, highlighting activities related to urban forestry and heat island reduction, and received an update on the Asheville Greenworks program, including the introduction of a new Community Forestry Coordinator and an upcoming urban heat island mapping study.
In a key decision, the commission approved a recommendation for a framework to distribute fee-in-lieu funds, which will be sent to City Council. The motion was amended to include "one or more members of the UFC" on the proposed task force and passed unanimously. Additionally, the commission discussed the need to streamline the recommended species list to focus on native and pollinator-friendly plants. The meeting concluded with a discussion on rescheduling the July meeting due to the holiday and planning for a spring social.
Community Input A public commenter expressed concern regarding the golf course project, stating that the landscaping company repeatedly parked trucks and heavy equipment on the roots of trees not scheduled for removal. The commenter reported that mature, healthy trees were removed for golf purposes, some without indicator ribbons, and that pruning was done with flush cuts that prevented healing. They questioned how an ISA-certified arborist could authorize such cuts and requested to see dates of arborist site visits. The commenter argued that the contractor should be held accountable for causing permanent damage to public property and noted a discrepancy in reports regarding the number of trees removed for golf purposes.
In response to the public comment, staff and members provided the following replies:
- Chris Collins (Staff): Addressed the concerns by stating the tree portion of the project is complete. He confirmed the arborist was present on pruning days. He clarified that only two trees not on the removal list were taken down, both of which had broken in a storm. He explained that brush clearing (trees <6 inches diameter) was a separate pursuit by the golf management company. He suggested using Google Street View to compare before/after images.
- Mark Foster (City Arborist): Acknowledged he was not happy with some pruning cuts on oak trees in the back nine. He stated he would ask the Public Works Director if a financial penalty under Chapter 20 should be pursued against the contractor. He noted that while he tried to manage the situation, the contractor may not have fully understood the expectations.
- Karen Macneil (Member): Asked about oversight and accountability. She noted that Chapter 20 has a $100 fee for improper pruning/removal and asked how this would be implemented.
- Chardin Detrich (Member): Questioned why the city hired a company without certified arborists on staff and why the city accepted a low bid that resulted in poor work. He requested before/after photos to verify which trees were removed.
- Cecil Bothwell (Member): Stated that the city is damaging its tree canopy to satisfy a small group of golfers and suggested letting the trees grow.
- Chris Collins (Staff): Responded to Cecil by explaining the financial model of the golf course, noting it is becoming self-sustaining and that revenue is reinvested in the course, potentially freeing up city funds for other projects like urban forestry.
Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:
- Karen Macneil agreed to step onto the Policy Working Group starting in May, replacing the Chair.
- Dawn Chavez agreed to talk to her team at Asheville GreenWorks about creating a campaign to encourage residents to contact City Council regarding urban forestry funding.
- Chris Collins agreed to send the current official tree species list to Keith Walsh.
- Karen Macneil agreed to send the updated species list information to Keith Walsh.
- Mark Foster agreed to ask Greg Schuller (Public Works Director) about pursuing a financial penalty against the golf course contractor for improper pruning/removal.
- Mark Foster agreed to go back to the golf course to inspect the pruning work on the pines in the front nine.
- Chris Collins and Mark Foster agreed to review areas where the contractor parked on tree roots to determine if remediation is needed.
- Chair Amy Smith agreed to send the scope of work for the Urban Forest Master Plan to Keith Walsh.
- Chair Amy Smith agreed to send an invitation for a spring social/picnic for the commission members.
- Staff (Nancy Watford) agreed to check with the design community regarding the recommended species list.
Impact This meeting highlights the commission's active role in balancing development with urban forestry goals. The approval of the fee-in-lieu framework provides a structured approach to managing funds from developers who opt out of planting requirements, which will be presented to City Council for final decision. The discussion on the golf course project underscores the ongoing challenges in overseeing large-scale landscaping projects and the importance of accountability for the health of the city's tree canopy. The commission's focus on budget advocacy and the municipal climate action plan demonstrates its commitment to integrating urban forestry into broader city sustainability efforts.
Meeting Video & Transcript