Skip to main content

Transit Committee – February 21, 2023

February 21, 2023 at 5:00 PM

  • 1 h 1 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Transit Committee Meeting Recap: February 21, 2023

The City of Asheville Transit Committee convened on February 21, 2023, to discuss transit operations, planning updates, and the committee’s 2022 annual report. However, the committee did not achieve a quorum, with only three members present. Consequently, no formal votes were taken on any agenda items, including the annual report or other motions. Chair Harvey Harold noted the lack of quorum, stating, "We do not have a quorum today... I can't vote on referrals and a review."

Key Discussions and Updates

Staff provided updates on several operational and planning matters. Regarding the vehicle fleet, staff discussed the cancellation of a purchase order for four Vicinity buses and the subsequent new purchase order for four Gillig buses. In terms of staffing, staff reported on ongoing driver shortages, with Assistant Director of Operations LaShawn Abrams stating, "We are down to 54 drivers... nevertheless, we're doing everything that we can to make sure that we are able to run all service." Abrams also confirmed that a controversial sign promoting drug use, which had been brought to staff's attention by the Chair, was removed from the bus. Additionally, staff notified the committee that Amy Tesner, Transit Financial Grants Analyst, left the transit department effective February 20, 2023, to work in the Human Resources department; staff is currently assessing how to fill the position.

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the preliminary planning for a Joint City-County Transit Plan serving both Buncombe County and the City of Asheville. Committee member Bill Loftus expressed concern that the committee needs to be involved in defining the scope of the $600,000 joint study before the contract is awarded. He cited a recent City Council approval of a development project without a transit plan, stating, "I don't want that happening anymore [transit being the last thing considered in development]. So my only ask is let's get on the front end of these things as opposed to the back end of these things so we can provide the appropriate input."

In response, Transit Planning Manager Amber Wagner stated that the process is still "extremely preliminary" and that the first meeting was only last week. She agreed that stakeholder involvement and scoping discussions will happen in upcoming meetings. Transit Projects Coordinator Catherine Lanier explained that the immediate goal is to secure funding to hire a consultant, after which stakeholders will be engaged to determine the focus of the analysis. Councilwoman Roni noted that the Transit Committee is a subcommittee of the Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC) and suggested the committee make recommendations to MMTC regarding their work plan to ensure their voice is heard.

Community Input and Advocacy Updates

A presenter from the advocacy groups "Better Buses Together" and "Just Economics" provided an update on bus signage and communications. The presenter reported that the digital sign over the customer service area has been slowed down to a readable pace but noted issues with the accuracy of arrival times, such as buses disappearing from displays after showing "3 minutes away." The presenter also reported an instance where a bus arrived with a digital sign displaying "input correct code" instead of the route number, causing rider confusion. The presenter confirmed that the city and management company are working on repairing audio announcements on all buses and that the city is looking into the cost of installing a laminated, system-wide map on all buses. The presenter requested that the committee support advocacy for clear, universal rules for riders regarding conduct to ensure consistent enforcement.

In response to the technical issues, Amber Wagner stated that staff is working proactively with the operations team and the Swiftly app team. She offered to replay specific incidents if the presenter provided details to diagnose technical issues with GPS or app configuration.

Decisions and Follow-Ups

Although no votes were taken due to the lack of quorum, several procedural agreements were made. The Chair agreed to strike the word "continuously" from the phrase "advocating continuously to continue the implementation of the Transit Master Plan" in the draft annual report. Staff confirmed that because the report has not yet been voted on, this revision can be made before it is brought back for a vote at a future meeting. Additionally, the Chair agreed to add an agenda item to a future meeting to discuss what specific items the Transit Committee would like included in the scope of the Joint City-County Transit Plan study.

Transit Planning Manager Amber Wagner agreed to include outreach on the scope of the Joint City-County Transit Plan in upcoming staff meetings and to provide updates to the committee.

Impact on Residents

This meeting highlighted the ongoing challenges in maintaining reliable bus service, including driver shortages and technical issues with digital signage and audio systems. The discussion regarding the Joint City-County Transit Plan is significant for residents as it involves a $600,000 study that will shape regional transit infrastructure. The committee’s push to be involved in the early scoping of this study aims to ensure that transit considerations are integrated into development and land use planning from the outset, rather than being an afterthought.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches