Skip to main content
  • 1 h 30 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Transit Committee Meeting Recap: December 20, 2022

The City of Asheville Transit Committee held a virtual meeting on December 20, 2022, from approximately 5:00 PM to 7:00 PM. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a discussion on a joint transit master plan with Buncombe County, updates on the W-5 bus route, a review of rider safety concerns, a presentation from the "Better Buses" group, and operational updates regarding vehicle procurement and fare technology.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the November 15, 2022, meeting and the minutes from the December 20, 2022, meeting. Additionally, the committee unanimously voted to recommend to City Council the concept of a joint planning effort with Buncombe County to develop a transit master plan. This recommendation includes a feasibility study for potential system consolidation.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the proposed joint transit master plan. Staff explained that the City has submitted a budget request for its share of the joint study, approximately $300,000, for the fiscal year starting July 1, 2023. The study aims to examine operational costs, new service types such as microtransit and vanpool, shared facilities, and governance structures. Staff noted that the committee’s specific role in the process is "yet to be determined" and that internal conversations with county staff are planned. Committee members expressed strong support for the initiative, with one member stating, "I think this is desperately needed. I'm in full and complete and total support." Another member noted that the County is currently updating its comprehensive plan, which includes support for this effort.

Regarding the W-5 route, staff discussed the potential removal of three stops: Hill Street, Westgate, and Patton at Resort. This discussion was influenced by the Sunrise Recovery Community Center’s move to the Westgate Shopping Center. Staff indicated they would continue to track stop-level data at the Westgate stops to inform future decisions. On rider safety, the committee discussed concerns regarding drivers taking off before passengers are seated, speeding, and riders standing up before the bus is fully stopped. Staff confirmed that it is policy to ask riders to remain seated until the bus is at a full stop and suggested laminating this rule or adding stickers to buses to reinforce it. Staff also noted they would look into adding this reminder to the "talking bus" announcements.

Community Input During public comment, a representative of the Asheville Regional Transit Coalition requested that the City and County partner to fund a feasibility study for consolidating transit systems, specifically requesting $300,000 in the City’s budget. In response, staff explained that the City has already submitted a budget request for its share of the study. Another public commenter, representing an organization that recently moved to the Westgate Shopping Center, urged the committee not to remove the Westgate stop, noting that their clients rely heavily on public transit. A colleague of the first commenter added that their organization spent $12,000 last year on bus passes. In response to these comments, a committee member suggested staff look into where these riders need to go to ensure they are served, and staff agreed to continue tracking data at the Westgate stops.

A public commenter raised concerns about driver behavior, including refusing to kneel the bus and leaving excessive space between the bus and the curb, as well as a security guard at the ART station banning homeless individuals. Staff responded by asking the commenter to share specific instances so they could pull video and address the situations appropriately. Another public commenter, representing the "Better Buses" group, highlighted ongoing issues with malfunctioning digital signage, app syncing delays, and the lack of paper maps on buses. A committee member agreed with these points, stating, "We are the reason the buses are here... We are customers because we pay our fare."

Follow-ups Staff agreed to have internal conversations with County staff regarding the joint planning effort. Regarding the W-5 route, staff stated they will review data for all three stops, particularly monitoring ridership at the Westgate stop, and may make minor adjustments in May. Staff also agreed to look into adding "remain seated" reminders to bus announcements and potentially laminating rider rules for display on buses. Additionally, staff stated they will provide the committee with an update on the FTA Triennial Review findings after the review is completed and hope to bring options for the Transit Fare Technology Project to external stakeholders, including the committee, in the next month or two.

Impact These discussions highlight the City’s ongoing efforts to improve transit efficiency and safety while addressing funding constraints. The recommendation for a joint master plan with Buncombe County signals a move toward regional cooperation to secure long-term funding and service improvements. The focus on the W-5 route and rider safety reflects the committee’s attention to the specific needs of vulnerable populations and the importance of clear communication and enforcement of safety protocols for all riders.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches