Historic Resources Commission – February 8, 2023
February 8, 2023 at 4:00 PM
- 3 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The Historic Resources Commission of the City of Asheville met on February 8, 2023, to review two primary agenda items: a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for the Louis Miller Griffith House at 65 Woodland Road and a new construction application for two structures at 109 Kingsland Alley. The Commission also approved the minutes from its January 11, 2023, meeting.
The Commission voted to approve the COA for the Louis Miller Griffith House, a local landmark, with specific conditions. The vote was not unanimous, with one member voting opposed. The approval included amendments to the application, such as removing proposed arched openings in favor of rectangular ones to distinguish new work from historic features, and requiring the installation of two custom kitchen cabinets designed by architect Ronald Green in the finished basement rather than removing them from the property. Additionally, the Commission required the applicant to sever the replacement of original light fixtures from the current application and return with further information regarding their condition. Staff noted that revised interior elevation drawings and basement floor plans must be submitted for review as a condition of the COA.
Regarding the new construction application at 109 Kingsland Alley, which proposes a primary residence and a garage on a lot behind 30 Watauga Avenue, the Commission voted unanimously to continue the application to the March meeting. The decision was made to allow the applicant time to revise the design, specifically addressing concerns about the roofline, porch detailing, and door materials to better align with the historic vernacular of the neighboring shingle house on Watauga Street.
During the discussion of the Griffith House, Chair Emily Kite expressed concern about the removal of features explicitly listed in the landmark’s Statement of Significance, stating, "I’m struggling a little bit because the designation is so very specific and includes a lot of very specific pieces of this building that are proposed to be removed... When designations talk very specifically about light fixtures and radiators and cabinets, what do we do?" Commissioner Annie McDonald stated that she could not support the removal of first-floor light fixtures as they are character-defining features. In response to the Commission’s concerns, the applicant’s architect, Jeff Dalton, argued that a landmark is not a museum, noting, "Just because something’s a landmark does not mean it never changes... We move walls, we move openings, we change light fixtures... It is not a museum, it’s someone’s home."
For the Kingsland Alley project, staff member Alex Cole expressed difficulty with the design of the primary structure, stating, "I don't know that it has a strong enough relationship with the structure on Watauga Street... I think the porch could be something that could relate more to the structure on Watauga Street." The architect, Diana Belgowan, explained that the porch could not be pulled out further without reducing the house size, which was already at 1,600 square feet. The owner’s representative, David Johnson, explained the preference for fiberglass doors due to weather resistance but agreed to submit smooth garage doors instead of wood-grain textured ones. Chair Emily Kite summarized the direction for the applicant, stating, "I think that we have direction, but I don't think that we're to a place where we can get approval because you can't really see what we're talking about."
The applicant for the Griffith House agreed to install the Ronald Green-designed cabinets in the basement, make new second-floor openings rectangular, and return with information on the light fixtures. The applicant for the Kingsland Alley project agreed to revise elevations to improve porch and roofline detailing, submit wood doors for pedestrian entrances, and revise the landscape plan to include additional plantings and screening for the mechanical unit. Staff also noted a pilot program with the North Carolina School of Government to analyze GIS and flood data to understand impacts on historic resources.
Meeting Video & Transcript