Skip to main content

Historic Resources Commission – January 11, 2023

January 11, 2023 at 3:59 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Dec 14, 2022 meetingNext: Feb 8 meeting
  • 5 h 47 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: January 11, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on January 11, 2023, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) and hold evidentiary hearings for properties within various historic districts. The commission began by accepting the minutes from the December 2022 meeting by unanimous vote. The agenda included five primary applications: the Louis Muller Griffith House at 65 Woodland Road, a project at 70 Cherokee Road, a residential project in Albemarle Park, curb ramp improvements in Biltmore Village, and three separate items within the Montford District.

The commission approved a Certificate of Appropriateness for the Louis Muller Griffith House at 65 Woodland Road, a Local Landmark. The applicant withdrew portions of the application related to first- and second-floor interior renovations and exterior door and window changes. The remaining approved items include the removal of wood paneling in the attic, the construction of a new stair to replace a spiral staircase, repairs to the existing stone wall, and the rebuilding of stone walkways and steps. The commission also approved the installation of new handrails, the conversion of a rear planting bed to a pea gravel patio, the creation of a kitchen garden with a painted picket fence, and the installation of two mechanical units. The COA was issued with the condition that stone samples for the terrace area be submitted to staff for approval.

For the project at 70 Cherokee Road, which involved replacing basement windows and doors, enclosing a side porch, and constructing a new shed, the commission did not take a final vote. The discussion focused on the need for scaled drawings, clarification on window materials, and structural support for the porch enclosure. The transcript ends before a final decision or continuance motion is recorded for this item. In Albemarle Park, the commission approved a COA for a residential project involving window and door replacements, the relocation of a kitchen window, and a porch enclosure. This approval included conditions requiring the submission of exact window specifications and revised elevation drawings to staff for review.

In the Biltmore Village district, the commission did not vote on the merits of a proposal to replace curb ramps with concrete. Instead, the commission voted to continue the item to the March meeting. This decision followed a discussion regarding conflicts between ADA compliance requirements, which favor concrete for maintenance and smoothness, and the district’s design standards, which mandate brick sidewalks. Staff noted that the development plan offers little flexibility for concrete in this area, while a City Public Works representative acknowledged that while brick is feasible to construct, long-term maintenance is difficult.

Within the Montford District, the commission approved a COA for the restoration of a 1908 house at 240 Flint Street, including porch, window, and door work, with no conditions. For the proposal at 25 Elizabeth Place to demolish a non-contributing structure and build two new multi-family residential buildings (16 units total), the commission unanimously approved the COA. This approval was conditional on the submission of stone and brick samples, chimney cap specifications, revised railing details, and revised elevation drawings for staff review. Finally, the commission unanimously approved a COA for the Bishop and Woodlawn property, allowing for a new painted wood picket fence, flagstone paving, and a wooden arbor with a swing.

Public comment was received for several items. Regarding 65 Woodland Road, a landscape architect, an architect, the property owner, and another architect presented arguments for the project, emphasizing the need to modernize the home for family use while preserving its character. The owner stated that the original deed restricted sale to persons of color, a restriction they had legally removed, and expressed a desire to unify the "servant's kitchen" into a family space. Chair Emily Kite stated that the commission is held to established standards and that a site visit to the interior would be of value to the board. For 70 Cherokee Road, a general contractor clarified that windows would be wood with 2x2 grilles and offered to provide scaled drawings. In Biltmore Village, a public commenter expressed disdain for after-the-fact approvals and suggested that concrete could be imprinted to look like brick or that brick could be used with a concrete underpinning. The commenter noted that their private enterprise successfully maintains brick sidewalks in the area. Members did not respond to this comment. For 25 Elizabeth Place, a public commenter who is a retired professional city planner and historic preservationist stated that the revised drawings represented a "creative improvement" and were "much more harmonious" with the historic Arts and Crafts style, recommending approval. Members did not respond to this comment. Staff reported that a resident of the Bishop and Woodlawn property had contacted them to object to the fence but was not present at the meeting; staff noted the commission could not give the absent feedback significant weight as it was not tied to specific design standards.

Staff and members agreed to several follow-up actions. Staff agreed to help the applicant at 65 Woodland Road amend the application to exclude withdrawn portions and requested stone and gravel samples for approval. The commission agreed to schedule a site visit to the interior of the 65 Woodland Road property. For 70 Cherokee Road, the applicant agreed to provide scaled drawings, clarify window materials, and provide information on porch structural support; staff advised that the shed application requires separate advertising and scaled drawings. Staff agreed to review revised drawings and window specifications for the Albemarle Park project at the staff level. For the Biltmore Village curb ramps, the applicant requested a continuance to the March meeting to revise the proposal. Staff indicated that if the application were denied, the applicant would need to propose a plan to correct the already-installed ramps and revise pending ones to align with district standards. For 240 Flint Street, staff stated he would follow up with the applicants in the next couple of days regarding outstanding details. For 25 Elizabeth Place, the applicant team agreed to submit revised elevation drawings and railing details for staff review. No specific follow-up actions were stated for the Bishop and Woodlawn property beyond the approval of the COA.

These decisions impact residents by determining the scope of renovations allowed on historic properties and the design standards for new construction in historic districts. The approval of the 65 Woodland Road COA allows the owner to proceed with specific interior and exterior modifications, subject to sample approval and a site visit. The approval of the 25 Elizabeth Place COA, subject to design revisions, allows for the construction of 16 new multi-family housing units in the Montford District. The deferral of the Biltmore Village curb ramp issue to March leaves the current concrete installations in place while the commission and applicant work toward a solution that balances accessibility with historic character.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches