Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – February 2, 2023
February 2, 2023 at 9:34 AM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: February 2, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) convened on February 2, 2023, to address housing policy, administrative updates, and market data. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous session, which were unanimously approved by the members present. The committee also voted unanimously to draft an amendment to its bylaws to allow for the position of co-chairs, a motion intended to be presented for final approval at the next meeting. This decision was driven by discussions regarding workload management and the need for clear conflict-of-interest guidelines, particularly as several members work on or are funded by city projects.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on source-of-income non-discrimination, prompted by recent news that the Hawthorne Apartments complex refused certain housing subsidies. Members debated the legal and practical implications of such refusals, with Councilwoman Mosley expressing concern that forcing individuals who only need temporary assistance onto the street could inadvertently increase the homeless population. Other members raised concerns about existing developments that accept vouchers only for smaller units, noting this can be discriminatory for families. The committee discussed the need for data on voucher acceptance and suggested polling developers of previously approved projects to understand how such policies might have affected their development decisions.
Staff presented a detailed review of the Land Use Incentive for Green and Economic (LUIGE) program, explaining its scoring matrix, tax increment financing mechanics, and monitoring processes. Staff clarified that the program does not use the term "rebate," as these are not legal in North Carolina, and that the city’s authority is limited to grants approved by Council. A new compliance program is being developed to request leases, rent rolls, income verifications, and proof of advertising for affordable units. Members expressed concern that current incentives may not adequately address the need for housing for voucher holders, with one member noting that completed LUIGE units may have very few voucher holders. Another member highlighted the disparity in funding between small units and larger family apartments. Staff indicated they would collect specific feedback from the committee via email to categorize questions for the policy revision process.
The committee reviewed its annual work plan, which includes timelines for a new Housing Plan, LUIGE policy revisions, and the Missing Middle Housing Study. Staff provided an update on the Missing Middle Housing Study, noting that the top candidate for the contract is Opticos, with Cascadia Partners as a sub-consultant. The project includes a displacement risk assessment funded by the Housing and Community Development (HCD) department. Staff stated they will present the contract to the Planning and Economic Development Subcommittee of Council on February 20, 2023, and to City Council on February 28, 2023, for approval. The committee was asked to identify appropriate members to serve on the study’s steering committee. Additionally, the committee discussed the idea of a "Developer Forum" to gather input on LUIGE and other policies, with staff suggesting this could be scheduled for the third quarter to align with the policy revision timeline. One member emphasized that if the committee invests time in a forum, it should give equal or greater weight to gathering input from low-income stakeholders.
Updates were also provided on homelessness and housing market data. Member David Bartholomew reported on a presentation by the National Alliance to End Homelessness, which recommended actions to decrease homelessness by 50% by 2025, with affordable housing construction as a key recommendation. The committee reviewed monthly housing market data, noting a brisk spring selling market where homes under $400,000 are selling quickly. There was a discussion on terminology, with members preferring the term "middle-income housing" over "workforce housing" to avoid confusion. The committee also reviewed a national ranking of Asheville as a place for renters, clarifying that the city ranks fifth for its size category, not fifth nationally.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff will draft the bylaws amendment for co-chairs for a vote at the next meeting. Jannice Ashley, Deputy City Attorney, will provide guidance on conflict-of-interest policies and recusal requirements for co-chairs, potentially at the March meeting. Staff will draft a Request for Proposal (RFP) or Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for the new Housing Plan, with two or three committee members reviewing the draft before it is finalized, aiming for discussion by the April meeting. Staff will also collect LUIGE feedback via email and assist the committee in identifying members for the Missing Middle Housing Study steering committee. Additionally, staff requested the committee’s help in promoting two upcoming HCD job openings: a Real Estate Coordinator position and a position vacated by Jonathan Jones. The committee agreed to continue advocating for the City to fund and designate an affordable housing ombudsman within Development Services as part of their annual report recommendations.
Meeting Video & Transcript