Affordable Housing Advisory Committee – March 6, 2023
March 6, 2023 at 9:33 AM
- 2 h 12 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: March 6, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) convened on March 6, 2023, to address committee governance, housing data, and pending policy questions. The meeting focused on amending the committee’s bylaws to allow for co-chairs, reviewing data on the Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) program, and discussing a pending application for micro-units.
Key Decisions The committee approved the minutes from the February 2023 meeting unanimously. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously to amend its bylaws to allow for the election of co-chairs. The amended language specifies that the Vice Chair position is optional rather than a fixed requirement, using the word "may" to provide flexibility in leadership structure. No vote was taken to elect specific co-chairs at this meeting, as the committee paused the process to seek legal guidance on conflict of interest.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the legal and perceptual implications of having members with financial interests in housing, such as developers, serve in leadership roles. Jannice Ashley, Deputy City Attorney, provided guidance on these issues, noting that while actual conflicts of interest require recusal, the committee must also consider the "appearance" of a conflict to maintain public credibility. Ashley clarified that the AHAC is an advisory body and that final policy decisions rest with the City Council.
The committee also reviewed a data-driven presentation from the Asheville Housing Authority regarding the HCV program. Michelle Moore, Co-Director of the HCV Program, highlighted the scale of the program, noting it serves approximately 3,000 low-income households. She described the ongoing challenge of keeping payment standards aligned with a rapidly inflating market, stating, "We have fought to increase our payment standards... and just as soon as we get that approved... the market explodes again." Moore also noted that the waitlist for those without referrals is currently longer than five years, with conversations suggesting it could reach ten years.
Regarding micro-units, the committee discussed a pending application but did not take a formal vote. Members debated the appropriate target demographic for such units, with one member questioning if the community needs units smaller than an efficiency, while another associated micro-units primarily with college students rather than families. The committee concluded that they lacked sufficient data, such as unit layouts and specific project details, to make an informed policy recommendation to the Housing and Community Development (HCD) department at that time.
Community Input A staff member reported receiving an email from a resident who stated they had submitted public comment, but the attachment or content was not visible. The staff member stated, "I will go back and try to find it, and I will send it to you all when I find it." No members responded to the specific content as it was unavailable, and the Chair acknowledged the situation and moved the meeting to a close. No other formal public comments were recorded.
Follow-ups Paul D’Angelo, Community Development Program Director, agreed to locate and forward the missing written public comment to the committee. He also committed to compiling a list of questions from committee members regarding micro-housing to gather more information for the next meeting. Additionally, D’Angelo stated he is working on a Request for Proposals (RFP) for the Affordable Housing Plan and hopes to get it out for comment before the end of the month. Staff from the Asheville Housing Authority stated they are open to providing HCV data in a different format to better illustrate voucher utilization, and the committee expressed interest in refining the monthly HCV report in a future meeting.
Impact These discussions aim to improve the transparency and effectiveness of the city’s affordable housing efforts. By clarifying leadership structures and conflict of interest protocols, the committee seeks to maintain public trust in its advisory role. The detailed review of HCV data highlights the critical role of the voucher program in housing low-income residents and the challenges posed by market inflation. The decision to gather more information on micro-units ensures that any future policy recommendations are based on comprehensive data regarding unit layouts and community needs.
Meeting Video & Transcript