Skip to main content

Board of Adjustment – January 19, 2023

January 23, 2023 at 1:58 PM

  • 16 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: January 23, 2023

The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on January 23, 2023, to conduct a quasi-judicial review of pending zoning variances. The primary agenda item for the session was an evidentiary hearing regarding a request to modify Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) standards for a property located at 17 Pinedale Road. The Board also addressed routine administrative matters, including the adoption of minutes from previous sessions.

The meeting began with the formal adoption of the minutes from the November and December meetings. This action was taken by unanimous vote, with all voting members in favor. Following the approval of the minutes, the Board moved to the substantive agenda item concerning the variance request at 17 Pinedale Road, which is zoned RS4 (Residential Single-Family).

The variance request involved the renovation of an existing accessory structure, originally built in 1949, into an ADU. The applicant sought relief from Section 7-14-13B of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), which currently limits ADUs to the lesser of 70% of the primary dwelling’s gross floor area or 800 square feet. Because the primary A-frame dwelling, built in 1950, is approximately 820 square feet, current code limits the ADU to roughly 530 square feet. The presenter, Mr. Starbaum, argued that this size is not a realistic living space in 2023 and emphasized that the applicant is utilizing a pre-existing structure rather than creating a new hardship. Mr. Starbaum stated, "The applicant has not created any hardships in this case that this is all as it was in before," and noted, "This is remarkably common. Life was much different in 1949... It is really difficult to have a structure that size today."

During the hearing, a public commenter spoke in support of the request, stating, "No new building, no new square footage will be added... I hope the board can see that my goal is just to refurbish an already existing structure and provide long-term housing in the city of Asheville." Chair Paul Wilczynski reminded the Board that it is a quasi-judicial body and that a four-fifths vote is required to grant a variance. Other Board members expressed support for the request; one member remarked, "This seems incredibly cut and dry to me," while another stated, "My initial motion to approve both. I don't see anything. Why not?"

The Board voted to approve the variance request for 17 Pinedale Road. A roll call vote was taken, with Ms. Godsey, Mr. Newman, Mr. Fundanish, Mr. Smith, and Chair Wilczynski all voting "aye." The motion to approve the variance was passed. No members of the public spoke during the separate public comment period, as the Chair asked if anyone wished to speak and there was no response recorded before the motion was made.

There were no specific follow-up actions or commitments explicitly agreed to by staff or members beyond the approval of the variance. The meeting was adjourned immediately after the vote. This decision allows the property owner to renovate the existing 1949 structure into an ADU that exceeds the standard size limitations, providing additional long-term rental housing within the city’s residential zones.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches