Board of Adjustment
December 19, 2022 at 1:59 PM
- 29 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: December 19, 2022
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on December 19, 2022, to address its agenda. The meeting began with Chair Paul Wilczynski noting that the minutes from November 2022 were not available for review. Consequently, the Board postponed the review and adoption of those minutes until the next meeting at which they are available. The Board then proceeded to the only evidentiary hearing on the agenda, which concerned a request for variances to floodplain development standards.
The primary discussion centered on a request from Nathaniel Webster of ARCA Design PLLC, acting on behalf of the owner Self Slope Apothecary Real Estate LLC. The applicant sought relief from the "substantial improvement" rule under the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). Typically, if a building is improved by more than 50% of its value, it must be brought up to full new construction flood standards, which require elevation or flood protection two feet above the base flood elevation. The applicant requested a variance to allow substantial improvements to the historic structures at 2 and 6 Brook Street without fully complying with those new construction standards.
Nancy Watford, Stormwater Supervisor in Development Services, presented the case, explaining that the buildings are "pre-firm" structures built before flood mapping and are contributing structures in the Biltmore Village Historic District. She noted that the project proposes elevating the floor of one building by 1.9 feet and flood-protecting all equipment to current standards. Watford stated, "They are pre-flood buildings... and they're on the historic registry... As part of this, there's no increase to danger of life, property, or materials swept into floodwaters because buildings exist now. And what they're proposing to do will actually increase some of the protection of the buildings, but not fully comply with new construction standards."
Alex Cole, the City staff liaison to the Historic Resources Commission (HRC), testified that the HRC design standards currently do not account for flood elevation requirements. This creates a conflict where full compliance with flood standards would violate historic preservation standards. Cole remarked, "This is a great example to me of when a variance should be approved because they basically if they had to you know meet the current new construction floodplain standards they would be out of they wouldn't be able to meet the the requirements of the design standards."
The Board voted on the request for variances to the floodplain development standards for substantial improvement for the commercial structures at 2 and 6 Brook Street. A motion was made to approve the variance requests and was seconded. Chair Paul Wilczynski called for a vote, and the motion passed 5-0. The recorded votes were Aye from Suzanne Vernon Godsey, Bill Newman, John Michael Kledis, Kristina White, and Paul Wilczynski. The request for the variance was approved.
Bill Newman commented on the decision, stating, "I feel like they're bringing the buildings into compliance as much as humanly possible in the historic district and anything that's in biltmore village is prone to flooding there's only so many structures that are in the more village that are going to have this unique situation where they have to request a variance and I think that they're doing as much as they can to comply with regulations."
There were no public comments during the meeting. The Chair asked if anyone from the public would like to comment, and upon receiving no response, closed the public comment period.
The only follow-up action explicitly agreed to at this meeting was the postponement of the November 2022 minutes until the next meeting at which they are available. No other specific follow-up actions were assigned to members or staff. This decision allows the owner of the Brook Street properties to proceed with substantial improvements to the historic buildings while implementing increased flood protections, such as elevating floors and protecting equipment, without being required to meet the full elevation standards for new construction.
Meeting Video & Transcript