Skip to main content

Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment – January 18, 2023

January 18, 2023 at 3:31 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Nov 16, 2022 meetingNext: Feb 21 meeting
  • 1 h 43 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment (SACIE) held a virtual meeting on January 18, 2023. The agenda covered the introduction of new committee members and the City Council liaison, updates on the single-use plastic reduction initiative, the formation of new City Council committees, the committee’s 2023 goals, procedural updates to bylaws, and the timeline for the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP).

Key Decisions

The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting via roll call, with ayes recorded from all present members. Regarding the committee’s name and structure, the committee unanimously voted to recommend to City Council that the body change its name from "Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment" to "Sustainability Advisory Committee" (SAC) and change all membership appointments to "at-large." The committee also accepted initial assignments for its three working groups: Stormwater and Green Infrastructure, Community Resilience, and Energy and Carbon. Notably, the committee did not vote on the first round of bylaws amendments. After discussion, the motion was rescinded to allow for a cleaner document to be presented at the next meeting. Finally, the committee agreed to hold a special meeting in February to review the final MCAP document.

Discussion Highlights

During the introduction of new members, Chair Tim Ormond remarked, "This is my first time as chair. I feel like one of the Royals but please be patient with any flubs." New City Council liaison Maggie Ellman clarified her role, stating, "I'm not a voting member. I'm not here to whip up your votes or anything, dominate or lead. I'm here to listen, learn, observe, and understand where y'all are at so that there's a clear line between council as policymakers and you all as strategic advisors."

Staff provided an update on the phased approach to regulating single-use plastics, noting that City Council has already prohibited single-use plastic bags for brush and leaf collection, effective August 1, 2023. Staff are currently conducting internal analysis and public engagement regarding further restrictions on point-of-sale bags and expanded polystyrene (styrofoam) foodware, with a recommendation to City Council scheduled for October. Regarding the bylaws, members clarified that conflict of interest language should strictly follow Board and Commission rules, leading to the decision to revisit the document at the next meeting.

In discussing the MCAP, an update to the 2009 Sustainability Management Plan, staff presented the status of the plan, which includes 22 recommended activities organized into three goal areas. Staff proposed a special meeting in February to review the final document and make a recommendation to City Council, aiming for a date that allows sufficient review time before the City Council’s strategic planning retreat on March 2-3.

Community Input

A public commenter raised concerns about the unintended consequences of banning single-use plastics, such as the increased use of polypropylene bags for grocery delivery in other cities, and asked if the committee was still considering alternatives like biodegradable plastics or fees. Staff responded that they had not yet made a recommendation to City Council on the broader issue and recommended taking more time for analysis and public engagement before making a final recommendation in October. Member Steven Baron clarified that the previous committee vote was unanimous on restricting single-use plastic bags for brush/leaf collection, but the 5-2 split was on the mandatory 10-cent fee for paper bags. He suggested the committee should look at the specific language used in the timeline to avoid confusion.

Another public commenter asked for a general figure on the city’s monthly energy spending for city buildings. Staff acknowledged the question but did not provide a specific figure in the transcript.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to provide the final MCAP document to the committee as soon as it is available, expected in mid-February, and to coordinate the special meeting date. Staff will also continue the public engagement and analysis process for the single-use plastic reduction initiative, with a recommendation to City Council in October, and support the committee in drafting the document explaining the name change and membership category changes. Committee members agreed to review the final MCAP document, work on the bylaws document to present a clean version for a vote at the next regular meeting, begin meeting in their respective working groups in the off-months, and draft the recommendation document for the name change and at-large membership categories.

Impact

These decisions establish the operational framework for the committee’s 2023 work, including the transition to a new name and at-large membership structure, which will be presented to the City Council Boards and Commissions Committee. The formation of specific working groups allows for focused progress on energy, stormwater, and resilience issues during months when the full committee does not meet. Additionally, the ongoing analysis of single-use plastics and the upcoming review of the MCAP will inform future City Council policy recommendations, directly impacting local environmental regulations and sustainability planning.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches