Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment – February 21, 2023
February 21, 2023 at 4:32 PM
- 56 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On February 21, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment (SACIE) held a virtual meeting. The primary focus of the session was the review and recommendation of the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP), along with the approval of the previous month’s minutes.
Key Decisions
The committee approved the minutes from the January meeting. The central decision of the session was a unanimous vote to recommend that the City Council adopt the Municipal Climate Action Plan. A motion to recommend adoption was made and seconded by committee members, and all present members voted in favor. Following this recommendation, the plan is scheduled to go to the Environment and Safety Committee before being presented to the full City Council.
Discussion Highlights
Staff presented an overview of the MCAP, explaining that it focuses on municipal operations and builds upon the 2009 Sustainability Management Plan and recent council resolutions, including the 100% renewable energy goal and climate emergency declarations. The plan outlines 22 specific activities grouped into three goals: making city assets efficient and resilient, embedding sustainability in decision-making, and supporting community resilience. Staff emphasized that the plan is a "living document," noting that priorities may shift as new opportunities, such as those arising from the Inflation Reduction Act, unfold.
Committee members raised several questions regarding the plan’s contents. Concerns were raised about the exclusion of microgrids from the top 22 priorities, the depth of building automation and retrofits, and the lack of specific sections on energy storage or regional transportation partnerships. Discussion also covered the balance between conventional "gray" stormwater infrastructure and "green" infrastructure, with staff stating that a solid framework is needed for both to ensure proper maintenance. Additionally, members inquired about funding mechanisms, including third-party financing, lifecycle cost analysis for vehicle purchases, and the use of bond programs. A staff member noted that third-party financing is "pretty tricky with our statutory abilities" and requires specific opportunities to determine if they fall within the city’s authority. The Vice Chair stated that while the plan is a good start, the lead departments identified in the document must focus on evaluating costs and funding requirements.
Follow-ups
Staff agreed to several follow-up actions during the meeting. They will review their notes to determine why microgrids were not included in the top 22 priorities, specifically examining the scoring criteria used. Staff also agreed to share documentation provided by a committee member regarding tree planting hole sizes with planning department staff working on landscaping code updates. Furthermore, staff will connect a committee member with the appropriate staff member to provide up-to-date information on the city’s participation in the FEMA Community Rating System. Staff offered to send links to finance presentations regarding bond programs and debt capacity to a committee member who asked about third-party financing. Finally, staff stated they would report on how priorities shift in future staff reports and likely link updates to the plan on the city’s webpage, though the exact format was not yet determined.
Impact
This meeting marks a significant step in the city’s climate strategy, as the advisory committee has now formally recommended the Municipal Climate Action Plan for adoption by the City Council. The plan provides a structured approach to making city operations more efficient and resilient while supporting community resilience. By recommending the plan, the committee has initiated the process that will lead to the full City Council’s review, ensuring that the city’s climate goals are integrated into its long-term planning and operations.
Meeting Video & Transcript