Skip to main content

Policy, Finance & HR Committee – January 10, 2023

January 10, 2023 at 10:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Apr 20, 2021 meetingNext: Feb 14 meeting
  • 1 h 27 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On January 10, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee convened to address three primary agenda items: the Finance Department’s update on the budget calendar and audit process, the City Attorney’s presentation of the 2023 legislative agenda, and an overview of the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) program. The meeting marked the first session for the newly combined committee, which merges the former Governance and Finance/HR committees.

Key Decisions

The committee took one formal vote during the session. A motion was made and seconded to adopt a resolution approving the 2023 City Council legislative agenda and directing the City Attorney to provide the resolution to the state legislative delegation. The chair called for a roll call vote, which passed unanimously (3-0) with Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Ullman, and Mayor Manhammer voting in favor. No other motions were recorded as having a final vote outcome at this meeting.

Discussion Highlights

The Finance Department provided an overview of the upcoming Fiscal Year 2024 budget process, highlighting a new opportunity for public comment at the February 28 City Council meeting. Staff also discussed the competitive process to select a new external audit firm, noting the city is at the end of its five-year contract with the current provider.

City Attorney Brad Branham presented the city’s nine-item legislative agenda for the North Carolina General Assembly. The agenda includes requests to oppose limits on local short-term rental regulation, support state funding for affordable housing, protect conditional zoning authority, update property taxation for homeowners, amend the Fair Housing Act to protect source of income/funds, allow civilian investigators for minor traffic incidents, support state/federal reparations, fund water quality improvements in the French Broad River, and authorize electronic meetings. Branham described the items as "incredibly impactful and important to a significant number of our community members" and noted that council members have been "extraordinarily helpful and active" in developing the largest legislative agenda during his tenure.

The Community and Economic Development Department presented the LUIG program, which uses projected future tax revenue to incentivize affordable housing in new developments. Staff detailed the scoring matrix and requirements, including a mandate that 20% of units be affordable at 80% Area Median Income for 20 years. Committee members debated potential policy revisions. Mayor Manhammer questioned whether the program is "worth it," noting the per-unit subsidy is "a little mind boggling" and suggesting a "buy-write multifamily process with a community benefits table" might be a better tool. Councilwoman Ullman urged staff to provide data on total units built in the community to contextualize the 337 LUIG units, describing the current data as "floating." Councilwoman Roney asked how the city ensures affordable units remain affordable and how the public can see who benefits from the tax incentives; the Community and Economic Development Director acknowledged that staff does not currently publish this data or report it to council regularly, identifying it as an area for improvement. Additionally, Mayor Manhammer expressed concern that the lowest-paid employees may not align with the current living wage, agreeing that knowing the new living wage amount sooner would help avoid a "shuffle at the end" of the budget process.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to several specific follow-up actions:

  • Audit Firm Selection: The Director of Finance stated that the city will release a Request for Proposals (RFP) for a new external audit firm that week. He and the Assistant Finance Director will review responses in the next month or two, potentially with help from the external Audit Committee. The committee will receive an update in March, and the new contract will go to City Council for approval in May.
  • Budget Process: Staff confirmed that the second-quarter financial report and proposed fees and charges adjustments will be presented to this committee at the February 14 meeting.
  • Living Wage Data: In response to a request from Councilwoman Roney, the Director of Finance stated that staff can provide data on overtime impacts on budgets and will look at previous living wage documents to help inform the current budget cycle.
  • Legislative Delegation Meeting: The Mayor stated that staff are working to schedule a meeting with the state legislative delegation, using a scheduling poll to find a date that works for all council members and legislators.
  • LUIG Policy Revisions: The Community and Economic Development Director stated that staff will hold a similar conversation with the Housing and Community Development (HCD) committee later in the month to determine criteria for policy revisions. Staff will also conduct stakeholder engagement with the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, developers, and internal staff. The Director of Finance confirmed that staff will "digest" the committee’s input and process it before returning with next steps.

Impact

This meeting established the operational direction for the newly formed Policy, Finance and HR Committee, setting the stage for the Fiscal Year 2024 budget cycle and the selection of a new external audit firm. The approval of the 2023 legislative agenda signals the city’s intent to actively engage with the state legislature on issues ranging from housing affordability and short-term rental regulations to traffic enforcement and water quality. The detailed discussion of the LUIG program highlights ongoing scrutiny regarding the cost-effectiveness of affordable housing incentives and the need for greater transparency in tracking how tax incentives benefit specific developments and residents.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches