Skip to main content

Finance Committee & HR

April 20, 2021 at 4:03 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Jan 10, 2023 meeting
  • 1 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On April 20, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee convened to discuss financial updates, water rate adjustments, and various general fund fee changes. The meeting began with an update from Tony McDowell, the newly appointed Chief Financial Officer, who introduced new finance staff members, including Caleb Lippard, the new Controller, and Holly Ohm, the Accounting Supervisor. McDowell noted that the committee needs to establish a permanent meeting time and date, as the current schedule is frequently rescheduled.

Water Rate Realignment Staff presented a proposal to recover approximately $7.5 million in lost revenue resulting from the elimination of the Capital Improvement Fee (CIP) following a court settlement. The plan involves a phased recovery over several years, starting with a roughly 6% increase in volumetric rates for most customer classes, excluding wholesale, along with adjustments to base fees based on meter size. Staff highlighted that the average single-family residential bill would rise from $56.86 to approximately $63.00, a figure that remains lower than the pre-CIP elimination rate of $65.38. Councilwoman Whistler, the Chair, noted that citizens often view the Metropolitan Sewerage District (MSD) and the Asheville City water system as one entity, suggesting the city should monitor this distinction. Councilwoman Turner expressed appreciation for the staff’s effort to balance the rates so that the current year did not feel like an overall increase compared to the previous couple of years.

General Fund Fee Adjustments Taylor Floyd, Budget Manager, presented recommended changes to several city fees, including new subdivision and design review fees for the Historic Resources Commission, reinstated sidewalk "fee in lieu" options, increased Nature Center admission fees, and minor increases to bus advertising rates. The proposal also included significant changes to parking rates, such as a $1 first hour/$2 subsequent hour structure in garages and stricter on-street time limits. However, staff recommended not increasing solid waste and stormwater fees in the upcoming fiscal year to limit financial impact on residents during the pandemic recovery. Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, stated that the city is trying to limit the impact of fee changes as the community recovers and that further work is needed on solid waste and stormwater.

Decisions and Votes The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to accept the staff’s proposal for the water rate realignment plan, with the recommendation to be presented to the full City Council on May 11. Councilwoman Turner moved the motion, which was seconded by Councilwoman Whistler. Regarding the other general fund fee adjustments, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to accept staff’s recommendations, with one specific modification: the first hour of garage parking will be free for the next fiscal year (2021-2022). Councilwoman Turner moved this motion, seconded by Councilwoman Whistler. Councilwoman Turner explained that making the first hour free would send a message of support for downtown businesses and encourage visitors to return. Councilwoman Kilgore agreed, stating that this change would likely encourage more activity for vendors and residents. Staff noted that this recommendation is subject to understanding the revenue impact of the free first hour.

Follow-Ups Staff member Beth agreed to provide options for a permanent monthly meeting time and date, checking availability with the three committee members to avoid conflicts with other meetings and budget work sessions. Tony McDowell stated that staff is working on gathering data regarding the history of Metropolitan Sewerage District (MSD) fees to compare with city water rates. He also agreed to add slides highlighting the impact of the water rate changes on commercial customers for the full Council presentation. Additionally, Ben Woody agreed to conduct a focused review of solid waste and stormwater needs in the fall or winter, with the intention of returning to the committee in November or December to propose rates for implementation in February or March.

Community Input There were no public comments recorded in this transcript. The chair confirmed with staff that there were no callers in the speaker queue.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches