Skip to main content

Noise Advisory Board – January 9, 2023

January 9, 2023 at 1:00 PM

  • 49 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: January 9, 2023

The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board held a regular meeting on January 9, 2023. The session focused primarily on the preparation of the board’s annual report and recommendations to City Council, as well as the election of 2023 board officers. The meeting began with the approval of minutes from the previous session and a review of a new staff report format that groups complaints by source and month, including a new public dashboard for year-over-year comparisons.

Key Decisions The board took several formal votes during the meeting. First, a motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from the December 12th meeting; the vote was unanimous, with all members voting "Aye." The board then conducted the election of officers for 2023. A motion was made and seconded to nominate Jessica Tomasin for re-election as Chair, which passed unanimously with all members voting "Aye." Similarly, a motion was made and seconded to nominate Rick Freeman for re-election as Vice Chair, which also passed unanimously with all members voting "Aye." The meeting concluded with the chair asking for objections to adjourning; no objections were raised, and the meeting was adjourned.

Discussion Highlights The primary discussion centered on four areas for the annual report to City Council. Regarding vehicular noise, the board discussed a recommendation to direct the City Manager to work with the Noise Advisory Board on revising the ordinance to address intentional engine revving and modified exhaust systems. Chair Jessica Tomasin expressed support for this recommendation, stating, "I personally think it's a good recommendation that I would love to put forward to City Council to let us have a chance to see if we can't tackle this and work with the city to get somewhere on it."

The board also discussed the status of the Waste Hauler recommendation, noting challenges in coordinating with city staff due to personnel leave. Vice Chair Rick Freeman stated, "My goal is to try again this week to get her attention. And I said she could make adjustments to the language... If I don't hear from her, I'll remove waste haulers from the recommendation, which is the only thing that she shared any concerns about." He further noted that the boundary between the board's work and the city staff's work is "by definition flexible," adding that any member can place an agenda item to discuss additional actions with staff.

Additionally, the board discussed a recommendation to conduct a new Citywide Ordinance Effectiveness Survey to gauge resident sentiment after the ordinance's first year. An update was provided on the Decibel Levels Working Group, which plans to conduct ambient and source noise measurements at complainant locations to evaluate current decibel limits. Member Jeff Santiago thanked Chair Tomasin and Vice Chair Freeman for their efforts, stating, "I think it's good to have you both continue to move forward with the momentum we've been building." Staff member Haley closed the meeting by expressing pride in the board's progress, saying, "I think you guys are on a great track for 2023."

Follow-ups Staff member Haley agreed to fix the broken link to the new public dashboard on the agenda and to investigate why the link was not working. Haley also agreed to email Daniel or Todd regarding the status of "ongoing investigation monitoring" mentioned in the staff report. Vice Chair Rick Freeman stated he would try to contact the city sanitation leader again that week to address the Waste Hauler recommendation. He noted that if he did not hear from her, he would remove waste haulers from the recommendation language to avoid conflicts of interest regarding future Requests for Proposals (RFPs). Additionally, the Decibel Levels Working Group plans to divide "no violation" reports into seasonal and non-seasonal sources in the next month to begin collecting data on non-seasonal sources.

Impact These discussions and decisions establish the direction for the Noise Advisory Board's engagement with City Council for the coming year. By finalizing recommendations on vehicular noise, waste hauler operations, and ordinance effectiveness, the board is preparing to address specific resident concerns regarding noise pollution and public safety. The upcoming survey and decibel measurements will provide data to evaluate whether current noise limits are effective, while the officer elections ensure continuity in the board's leadership. The next regular meeting of the Noise Advisory Board is scheduled for Monday, February 13, 2023, and will be held virtually.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches