Reparations Commission
December 5, 2022 at 5:54 PM
- 2 h 18 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Community Reparations Commission approved the meeting agenda and minutes unanimously. The primary decision of the meeting was the adoption of the first formal recommendation, titled "Stop the Harm." This recommendation calls on the City of Asheville and Buncombe County to cease institutional processes that lead to racially disparate outcomes in education, health, housing, economic development, and justice. It also demands an official audit to verify compliance with federal and state laws. The recommendation was amended to specify that the audit would be conducted by a third party via a competitive procurement process, with a timeline provided by the external auditor and reported to the Commission. The motion to adopt the recommendation, including these amendments, passed via roll call with all present members voting "Yes." The final recommendation will be sent to the City Council and County Commission.
Discussion Highlights
The Chair opened the meeting by acknowledging the unprecedented nature of the commission’s work, describing it as "building the plane as it flies." The Chair urged members to remain proud of their productivity while considering how the commission would organize if its recommendations were ultimately rejected, stating, "Suppose after all this work we are told no... The question is how will we organize when we are told no? Keep it in mind." The Chair also addressed a sensitive internal matter regarding a survey response indicating physical confrontation between two members, emphasizing that safety is paramount and that all members are on an "equal playing field." A member responded, "If we're going to do something productive, we need to feel like we're in a safe space to do that."
Updates from the Impact Focus Areas (IFAs) covered several key areas. The Economic Development IFA presented a recommendation to support business incubators in historically Black neighborhoods, noting that African American businesses received less than 1% of city procurement spend in recent years. The Housing IFA reported on efforts to identify city and county-owned properties and their role in historical harm. The Criminal Justice IFA shared that data was used to help enact "Ban the Box" policies in Asheville, Buncombe County, and Mission Health. The Education IFA discussed teacher retention, Black educator cohorts, and a proposal to address excessive suspensions of Black students. The Health & Wellness IFA outlined eight recommendation areas, including free access to healthcare, eliminating bias, and supporting Black-owned health centers.
Regarding data, the County’s Director of Strategy & Innovation provided an update on the 69 data requests received from the IFAs, noting that while all requests have been assigned, historical data gaps, particularly pre-1950, present challenges. A member commented, "If you make recommendations without data, we're gonna have just a lot of empty conversation." Another member, Dwayne Barton, stated, "We don't have to start A in the alphabet. We are on P." A member also used a military analogy, stating, "As an airborne qualified soldier, I know where the drop zone is... It is still delivered and it hasn't happened. So tell me when it's supposed to happen and then we can pivot from that point."
The City and County presented updates on community engagement, including a proposal to partner with Asheville Writers in the Schools to document the reparations process through youth-led media. Sekou Coleman of Asheville Writers in the Schools stated, "We will be documenting the actual work that y'all are doing along with youth members... a way for us to tell our story and not allow others to tell the story for us."
Community Input
A public commenter congratulated the commission on the partnership with Asheville Writers in the Schools. The commenter proposed a "slavery disclosure ordinance" requiring businesses that profited from slavery to disclose this when contracting with the city, with penalties funding reparations if they fail to do so. The commenter also invited the commission to learn about the "Reparations Stakeholder Authority of Asheville," a community-controlled entity that could disperse funds in ways municipal government cannot. Members did not respond to the comment.
Follow-ups
Christine Edwards, Project Manager, stated that updated project timelines and structures for connecting IFA recommendations to data will be shared with members leading up to the January meeting. Rafael, Director of Strategy & Innovation for Buncombe County, agreed to follow up with the county’s procurement team to understand data limitations regarding African American business contracting and report back to the Project Manager. Leonard Jones, Buncombe County Communications, agreed to cross-reference his faith leader contact list with a commissioner’s list to ensure broader outreach to Black churches. The Economic Development IFA will provide a written recommendation to the full commission by the end of the week for consideration at the next meeting.
Impact
This meeting marked the formal adoption of the commission's first recommendation, signaling a shift from data gathering to actionable policy proposals for the City of Asheville and Buncombe County. The "Stop the Harm" recommendation, which includes a third-party audit, will now be presented to the City Council and County Commission for their consideration. The discussions highlighted the ongoing challenges of historical data gaps and the importance of community engagement in documenting the reparations process.
Meeting Video & Transcript