Skip to main content
  • 2 h 12 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Key Decisions

The Asheville/Buncombe County Reparations Commission formally established five Impact Focus Area (IFA) work groups: Criminal Justice, Economic Development, Education, Health and Wellness, and Housing. A motion to establish these groups was made and seconded, and the vote passed with one member voting opposed. Additionally, the commission approved the minutes from the August 15 meeting by unanimous consent. No vote was taken on the reassignment of the project management contract; staff informed the commission that this reassignment will be presented to the Asheville City Council for approval on the consent agenda the following Tuesday.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the transition of project management duties. Staff informed the commission that Deborah Clark-Jones, the current project manager from Techquity, is stepping down due to scheduling conflicts, and Christine Edwards, who joined the team in September, will assume the leadership role. Staff also presented results from post-meeting surveys for the August 15 and September 23 meetings, noting feedback that indicated a desire for more action-oriented meetings, better organization, and clearer communication regarding data and next steps.

Data access emerged as a central challenge, with discussion centering on delays in receiving requested data from city and county staff, which is hindering the work groups' ability to develop evidence-based recommendations. The Chair introduced a draft document titled "Recommendation for Immediate Action: Stop the Harm," which synthesizes inputs from previous speakers and UN declarations; this document was placed on the agenda for the next meeting for detailed discussion.

Superintendent Ronald Gates, Senior Pastor of Greater Works Church of God in Christ and Chairman of the Eagles Wings Community Development Corporation, presented his organization’s work. He described the nonprofit’s mission to create permanent affordable housing and mixed-use income opportunities, noting it consists of approximately 80 churches spanning from Texana Murphy to Hickory, North Carolina. Gates highlighted partnerships with First Bank, Buncombe County, Dogwood Health Trust, and the LIS Corporation, as well as a project on Ashland Avenue and a collaboration called "Work Build" with Grace, Marietta, and Charlotte, North Carolina, aimed at stimulating trade in plumbing, electrical, carpentry, and masonry.

Community Input

During public comment, a resident expressed concern that only eight out of 30 commission members responded to the recent survey, urging that all members respond to ensure the commission accurately represents the group's thoughts. No specific member replied directly to this comment. Another public commenter noted feeling "blindsided" by the project management transition and the cancellation of the October meeting without prior explanation. Assistant City Manager Brenda Mills apologized for the lack of explanation regarding the October meeting cancellation, stating, "I do apologize. You will get explanations in the future."

A public commenter representing the Health and Wellness IFA stated that despite multiple requests and direct emails to staff, they had not received the necessary birth and health data from Buncombe County, preventing their group from completing its work. Assistant City Manager Brenda Mills responded by stating, "We have all of your data requests... you'll have a response by the end of the week about where your data request is." She noted that some requests are for records the city possesses, while others require research or data from other organizations.

Another public commenter asked that existing community development plans from Black neighborhoods, specifically Shiloh, Burton Street, and East St. Paul, be brought before the commission for immediate recommendation consideration. A commission member noted that the plans for Shiloh and Burton Street are already on the record and available on the city website. A final public commenter urged the commission to be honest about its goals, stating, "This is not a term... We're not doing reparations. We're doing a housing voucher program maybe, community reinvestment process." The commenter warned that the current path leads to "litigation and more holdup" and advised the body not to "shoot your own selves in the foot." No member responded to this specific comment.

Follow-ups

Assistant City Manager Brenda Mills committed to providing a status update on all outstanding data requests by the end of the week. She also stated that the contract reassignment to Christine Edwards will go to the Asheville City Council on the following Tuesday for approval. The Chair stated that the "Stop the Harm" document will be discussed in depth at the next meeting, which is scheduled for December 7th. The Vice Chair directed that each IFA spokesperson will report to the full commission at every future meeting.

Impact

This meeting marked a structural shift in the commission's operations by formally creating the five work groups that will drive the reparations process. The emphasis on data access highlights the commission's reliance on evidence-based recommendations, a point reinforced by a commission member who stated, "We got people out there who have been here all their lives and who suffer more so than most people and endured it in silence. And so we're going to have to use data to inform every decision and recommendation because as you all know, we are a litigious society." The transition of project management to Christine Edwards signals a new phase in the commission's administrative support, with the incoming manager expressing that she is "incredibly honored to be a part of this process" and noting that she learned "the city leadership is bold in their leadership of moving forward with this reparations commission."

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches