Design Review Committee
November 17, 2022 at 12:32 PM
- 1 h 6 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: November 17, 2022
The City of Asheville Design Review Committee convened on November 17, 2022, to address administrative matters, conduct formal and informal design reviews, and discuss future topics related to stormwater management. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a formal review of a historic building modification, two informal reviews of mixed-use and residential developments, and a discussion on green infrastructure.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the October 20, 2022 meeting. Regarding the formal design review for 102 North Lexington Avenue, a motion was made and seconded to accept and approve the recommended approval of the project; all members voted in favor, and the project was approved. For an unspecified Item B, a motion was made and seconded to continue the item to the December 15 meeting, and all members voted in favor. No formal votes were taken on the informal reviews for 159 Riverside Drive or 175 Lyman Street, as the Chair clarified that these stages do not involve formal voting. The meeting was adjourned by unanimous vote.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the reconstruction of the historic mill building at 159 Riverside Drive. Alex Cole, Historic Preservation Planner, noted that staff concerns were limited to retaining original storefront and window features, as guidelines recommend preserving these elements. Jeremy Goldstein, Vice Chair, expressed concern that the project involved taking down and rebuilding the structure rather than adaptive reuse, stating, "if you're gonna use it you prepare to use it for everybody not just [this project]." In response, Alex Cole suggested that the department needs to be more explicit in defining the type of historic preservation required for such projects in the future. Project architect Peter Alvarez assured the committee that all old brick would be used, with any new brick remaining unseen. Steven Lee Johnson recommended approval, noting he found the new design exciting, while Robin Raines expressed regret over the loss of the original brick angle. Chair Christina Roush concluded that the design met the spirit of the intention and that the height change was not problematic.
The committee also discussed stormwater management and green roofs in the context of the 175 Lyman Street (Woodfield Stoneyard) project. Bryan Moffitt argued that the site presented a "missed opportunity" to maximize green stormwater infrastructure, citing Philadelphia as a successful example of using such measures to save money and improve water quality. A public commenter of Civil Design Concepts encouraged the community to increase education on green roofs, noting that the proposed depressed area on the west side of the building would function similarly to a rain garden to manage courtyard and roof drainage.
Community Input One public comment was received regarding 175 Lyman Street, with a commenter expressing concern that the number of parking spaces was too high for the area. Additionally, a separate comment noted that the west side of the building facade was "devoid of any activity." In response to the concern about the west side, a public commenter stated, "We certainly want to look at that. It will be a depressed area. I think it will serve some function of some stormwater control... I think it'll function a lot like that [a rain garden]."
Follow-ups Staff committed to clarifying the path forward for 159 Riverside Drive, specifically whether the changes required a formal amendment to the conditional zoning or could be handled as a minor modification. Staff stated they would get back to the applicant before Thanksgiving to resolve this. Additionally, staff indicated that the feedback from the 175 Lyman Street review would be presented to City Council at the December 15 meeting. The committee also agreed to discuss green roofs and innovative stormwater management in more detail in the future, with a suggestion to work with the stormwater task force to provide educational sessions to architects and developers.
Impact These decisions affect the preservation and development of historic and new properties in Asheville. The approval of the 102 North Lexington Avenue modification allows for changes to an early 20th-century contributing building. The ongoing review of 159 Riverside Drive highlights the tension between modern development and strict historic preservation standards, potentially leading to clearer guidelines for future adaptive reuse projects. The discussion on 175 Lyman Street underscores the committee’s interest in integrating green infrastructure into new developments to manage stormwater more effectively, a topic that will continue to be explored in future meetings.
Meeting Video & Transcript