Skip to main content

Design Review Committee

October 20, 2022 at 12:15 PM

  • 2 h 55 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Recap: October 20, 2022

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on October 20, 2022, to review three development proposals and address administrative matters. The agenda included formal reviews of the Ashton & Sawyer Micro-Housing project at 46 Aston Street and the Woodfield Stoneyard project at 175 Lyman Street, as well as an informal design review of the Asheville Tributes Apartments/Hotel at 68 Carter Street. The committee also voted on the format for future meetings, deciding to return to in-person sessions beginning the following month.

The committee approved the draft action minutes from the previous meeting unanimously, with seven ayes and no nays. Regarding the meeting format, a motion to remain virtual for the next year failed with three ayes and five nays. Consequently, the committee will resume in-person meetings, starting next month in the City Hall first-floor north conference room. Vice Chair Jeremy Goldstein supported the return to in-person meetings, stating that being in person makes him "much more focused" and that there is "no comparison" to the relationships built with applicants, the public, and fellow members in that setting.

For the 46 Aston Street proposal, which includes two seven-story buildings with 231 micro-housing units and a renovated garage for retail and dining, the committee voted to recommend approval with eight ayes and no nays. This recommendation is subject to the condition that the applicant provide a suitable alternate material to the horizontal lap siding. Member Bryan Moffitt noted that horizontal lap siding is not an appropriate material for a "deeply urban project" in a downtown context.

The committee also voted to recommend approval for the Woodfield Stoneyard project at 175 Lyman Street, a six-story mixed-use building in the River Arts District featuring 263 residential units. The motion passed with all voting members casting aye votes. Approval is contingent on several conditions: the applicant must incorporate specific material colors, fenestration, and detailing from concept renderings, including three red vertical Corten elements, brick detailing, arches, and storefront mullions; incorporate a green roof and other stormwater control measures to the best of their ability; and return to the commission for a courtesy review after implementing these changes.

During the discussion of Woodfield Stoneyard, members emphasized the need for the design to reflect the River Arts District context. Chair Christina Roush expressed a desire for the project to look "uniquely Asheville" rather than resembling typical buildings from other cities, and asked the team to consider opening up the internal courtyard for more access. Member Ricardo Seijo urged the architecture to "do the work" to reflect the river-facing location, encouraging the team not to rely on murals. Member Steven Lee Johnson stated that a full green roof is a critical sustainability requirement for downtown Asheville to mitigate urban heat island effects and manage stormwater.

The committee conducted an informal review of the Asheville Tributes project at 68 Carter Street, a mixed-use development featuring hotel rooms, residential condos, and rooftop amenities. No vote was taken on this item. Member Bryan Moffitt criticized the Anne Street facade for feeling like a "parking deck" and requested a well-designed, activated pedestrian space with seating and grouped trees. Member Ricardo Seijo suggested the facade respond to the site’s steep grade in three dimensions to create pedestrian opportunities. Member Steven Lee Johnson reiterated that a full green roof is necessary for his support, while Member Kathryn Ancaya clarified the difference between a decorative roof garden and a functional green roof for stormwater infrastructure, noting that a simpler system can still provide significant benefits.

Staff member Will agreed to check with colleagues regarding a Uniform Development Ordinance (UDO) code clarification on whether a building stepping down to one story on one side meets the "two occupiable stories" requirement for all frontages. Will also agreed to check the number of live viewers for the virtual meeting to inform future format decisions. The developer team for Woodfield Stoneyard agreed to revise the design to better reflect the River Arts District context, including revisiting salvaged brick, incorporating more Corten elements, adjusting the color palette, and providing additional renderings. The developer for 68 Carter Street stated the team would explore feedback regarding the Anne Street facade, green roof, and pedestrian activation before a formal review.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches