Public Safety Committee
November 17, 2022 at 11:05 AM
- 55 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: November 17, 2022
The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee convened on November 17, 2022, to review police department contracts, federal grant applications, and community response initiatives. The meeting agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of the Asheville Police Department (APD) budget and contracts, and presentations on alternative community safety programs.
Key Decisions and Votes The committee took action on five items during the meeting. First, the committee unanimously (3-0) approved the minutes from October. The committee then voted on four APD-related items, all of which passed with a 2-1 vote. Councilwoman Roney voted "No" on all four items, citing a lack of budget transparency, while Councilwoman Kilgore and Vice Mayor Shanika Smith voted "Aye." The approved items included:
- Renewal of the LexisNexis Virtual Crime Center contract for a second and final term.
- A new contract with ColePro Media LLC for transparency engagement advising services, including two optional renewals.
- Application for and receipt of the 2022 Edward Byrne Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) in the amount of $80,145.
- Application for and receipt of the 2022 Bulletproof Vest Partnership Grant in the amount of $10,163.61.
Discussion Highlights Councilwoman Roney explained her dissenting votes by stating, "I need to let folks know that it is the council's duty to oversee the budgets, plans, and policies of the organization as a whole. This committee is still lacking the requested update on fiscal year up to date budgets and projections... Until we have updates on our budget, my no vote on grant funding is directed at not approving increases to budget that lack transparency."
The meeting concluded with presentations on community response efforts. Fire Chief Scott Burnett presented an update on the City of Asheville’s proposed Community Responder Pilot Program, noting that the pilot is proposed to have a multidisciplinary team to complement Buncombe County’s efforts. He stated, "Our pilot program is proposed to have a multidisciplinary team and that will complement Buncombe County's efforts... to not only respond but most importantly be proactive to address our community safety and quality of life issues... before they escalate." Taylor Jones from Buncombe County also spoke, praising the collaborative approach: "The model that we're going down the road to create right now... this co-responding model is really the best because it's really gonna take all of us coming together, all hands on deck approach... I just applaud everybody's effort because this blending of ideas and working together is really what our community needs right now." Councilwoman Roney expressed caution regarding the new staffing, stating, "My concern is for success and support of these new potential staff members... I think it needs to be done carefully and right, not just fast."
Community Input Five members of the public called in to comment, primarily focusing on police staffing, salaries, and the transformation of the committee.
- One commenter from the Asheville Coalition of Public Safety expressed full support for the grants and argued that voting against them indicates a lack of support for public safety. They emphasized the need to raise police salaries to remain competitive with other departments, stating, "We are going to lose officers to these higher paying locales if we don't take action... It is really absolutely crucial that we get on track."
- Another commenter requested the removal of Councilwoman Roney from the committee and asked for a plan to make APD salaries competitive. They stated, "Pass the JAG grant and the bulletproof vest route unanimously and send it to Council."
- A third commenter, identifying as a lifelong Democrat and member of the Asheville Coalition for Public Safety, thanked public servants and requested support for police requests, arguing that "We only see the news every day... Those are not situations to call a social worker for."
- A fourth commenter from Montfort thanked the council and chiefs for their service but called for clear leadership, transparency, and metrics on accountability. They suggested, "Perhaps council should consider putting out a referendum to get, let the citizens weigh in on this."
- A fifth commenter, a co-founder of the boards and commissions realignment work group, raised concerns about the transformation of the Public Safety Committee into the Environment and Safety Committee. They noted that mixing issues like recreation, stormwater, and climate with public safety required a plan, stating, "I am all about climate... I can tell you just walking into mixing these kinds of issues... it needed a plan."
Vice Mayor Smith thanked the callers after the public comment period. No specific member or staff member responded to the individual requests or concerns raised by the public commenters during the meeting.
Follow-ups Fire Chief Scott Burnett stated that the city is working to outline specific issues for the Community Responder Pilot, develop a detailed action plan, and identify staffing needs. He explicitly agreed to provide another update to the Public Safety Committee in early spring. Assistant Fire Chief Patrick Kruda was identified as the program manager for the pilot and will provide updates moving forward. Councilwoman Roney asked staff to provide a future analysis of non-emergent calls for service from the last six months to two years; staff did not explicitly agree to this specific analysis, though Chief Burnett indicated they are gathering information for the pilot.
Impact These decisions directly affect the resources available to the Asheville Police Department and the structure of community safety services. The approval of the JAG and Bulletproof Vest grants provides specific federal funding for police operations and equipment, while the LexisNexis and ColePro contracts support crime data analysis and public transparency efforts. The ongoing development of the Community Responder Pilot Program signals a shift toward multidisciplinary approaches to public safety, aiming to address quality of life issues proactively alongside traditional law enforcement.
Meeting Video & Transcript