Skip to main content
  • 1 h 16 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: October 25, 2022

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on October 25, 2022, to address police recruitment, emergency planning, and community concerns. The only formal decision made during the session was the approval of the minutes from the previous September meeting. Councilwoman Kim Roney seconded the motion, and Vice Mayor Shanika Smith called for a roll call vote. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore, Councilwoman Roney, and Vice Mayor Smith all voted "Aye," resulting in the unanimous approval of the minutes. No other formal votes or motions were recorded.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to public comment, during which four residents called in to express strong support for the Asheville Police Department (APD) while raising concerns about staffing levels and specific council actions. Commenters highlighted that the department is currently 40% understaffed, arguing that this deficit encourages criminal activity and leaves residents vulnerable. Several speakers criticized Councilwoman Kim Roney for voting against providing police with safety equipment and for her stance on encampment clearances. One resident asked, "Next time I'm fearful for my family's safety, who am I supposed to call?" Another commenter argued that using Asheville as a "lab experiment" for justice policies is an overreaction and that compassion for the homeless does not mean allowing them to remain on the street if they refuse help. The committee members did not respond to these public comments during the meeting.

The committee also reviewed an update on APD recruitment efforts, presented by Captain Brandon Moore on behalf of Chief David Zak. The presentation covered the launch of the "EPIC" recruitment website, social media campaigns, and the status of the Integrity and Compliance Unit. Captain Moore emphasized that the city has not reduced its hiring standards, stating, "We have not reduced our standard... the city of Asheville is maintaining its hiring standard for police officers is the same as always had so that we can get the qualified candidates, not just a candidate." Chief Zak clarified that the recruiting effort is a broad-based program spanning years, targeting specific groups with individual campaigns rather than restricting identification to a particular demographic. City Manager Deborah Campbell added that this is a phased, additive process and not the department's only recruitment effort.

In response to questions regarding the cost of living and its impact on recruitment, City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that information regarding pay adjustments and a six-month budget snapshot will be provided to the Finance and Human Resources Committee and included in the manager's report at the upcoming council meeting. Additionally, Vice Mayor Smith requested that staff bring back analytics data before additional targeted advertising dollars are spent. Chief Zak noted that a three-month snapshot, expected in late December or early January, would provide more reliable data than the current 20-day figures.

The final agenda item involved a presentation by Fire Division Chief Jeremy Knighton on the Request for Proposals (RFP) process for updating the city’s Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) and Continuity of Operations Plan (COOP). Chief Knighton reported that 15 proposals were submitted from nationally respected companies, with 13 found to be responsive. He noted that all proposals were within budget and timelines, with each concluding around the June-July 2023 timeframe. When asked about public access to RFP documents, Chief Knighton stated that the scope of work and scoring matrix are available on the city’s purchasing website, but he deferred to the finance team regarding the release of specific application details due to non-disclosure agreements.

Looking ahead, the city will work with Community Engagement and Public Education (CAPE) staff to develop a communication and engagement plan for the new EOP/COOP, with outreach efforts indicated to begin in early 2023. Staff will also provide a report on the success and demographics of the APD recruitment campaign. These updates will help residents understand the city's ongoing efforts to address police staffing shortages and modernize emergency preparedness protocols.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches