Urban Forestry Commission
November 1, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: November 1, 2022
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on November 1, 2022, to address a range of agenda items including alternative compliance cases, the Municipal Climate Action Plan, staffing updates, and the planning of the 2023 annual retreat. The meeting began with the approval of the previous meeting’s minutes, which passed with 6 ayes and 1 abstention.
The Commission made several key decisions regarding tree management and policy. A motion to accept the revised landscape plan for 346 East Stanley Drive passed unanimously with 7 ayes. Similarly, a request to modify street tree requirements for One Battle Square passed unanimously with 7 ayes, conditional on appropriate tree protection during renovation. Regarding the 2023 annual retreat, the Commission voted to hold the event in person in January, with the motion passing 6 ayes and 1 no. By consensus, the specific date was set for Friday, January 13, 2023.
Significant discussion centered on the Municipal Climate Action Plan, presented by the City’s Sustainability Director. Chair Amy Smith emphasized the importance of unified advocacy, stating, "The more voices that are pushing toward the same outcome, then the more likely we'll be able to get that funding." Dawn Chavez noted that the plan strengthens the call for including trees and stormwater benefits in climate goals. The Commission also reviewed updates from various working groups, deciding not to create a separate working group for invasive species at this time, but instead incorporating the topic into the Urban Forest Master Plan and policy discussions. A new working group for the Recommended Species List was formed, consisting of Karen Macneil, Sharon Summerall, and potentially Dawn Chavez, to address issues such as the misclassification of columnar trees.
Public comment was received from a resident who submitted an email urging the Commission to help protect trees on private property, specifically citing the removal of eight mature oaks at a church to build a parking lot. In response, Chair Amy Smith stated she had spoken with the commenter and suggested channeling advocacy through networks like the Tree Protection Task Force to pressure City Council. Member Patrick Gilbert noted that state law largely prohibits municipalities from intervening in private property rights. Member Ed Macy expressed concern, stating, "I think that we have to strongly advise the city to move in a direction that enables us to save some of these larger old heritage trees... We can't keep doing that." Member Sharon Summerall suggested looking at ordinances regarding grading over 300 square feet for businesses to require tree replacement. Additionally, a public commenter asked about the start date for the Vermont Street project and suggested the Commission invite a city representative to speak at the December meeting. A commission member responded, "Yeah, we can see if they will come. So for December, yeah, we can see if we can get that."
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Member Patrick Gilbert agreed to re-send the correct, dated version of the Chapter 20 ordinance document to staff to ensure they are working from the latest iteration, as Member Ed Macy raised concerns that staff might be using an older version. Gilbert also agreed to take the lead on the Policy Working Group to manage communications and progress on Article 19 and Chapter 20, and to task the group with looking into ways to affect tree removal on private property within state law. Member Karen Macneil agreed to send her draft heritage tree resolution to Member Ed Macy for review. Regarding staffing, staff confirmed the Urban Forester position was actively recruiting and noted the city would select an interim for the vacancy left by former staff member Ben. For the municipal golf course tree removal, the Commission will prepare specific requests and best practices, including a demand for a certified arborist report, to present when the project lead presents next month. Members Sharon Summerall and Cecil Bothwell offered to help water trees at Hillcrest Apartments and Klondike, respectively, with staff agreeing to contact them with details.
These decisions and discussions impact residents by shaping the city’s approach to urban forestry, climate resilience, and public engagement. The approval of alternative compliance cases ensures specific projects proceed with agreed-upon tree protections, while the formation of new working groups aims to refine species lists and policy frameworks. The focus on the Climate Action Plan and heritage tree protection highlights the Commission’s role in advocating for the preservation of mature trees and their environmental benefits within the city.
Meeting Video & Transcript