Skip to main content
  • 1 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: October 4, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission met on October 4, 2022, to address tree management issues, review staff reports, and vote on procedural matters. The agenda included a review of a specific property’s tree removal violation, updates on ongoing working groups, and a decision on the format of future meetings.

Key Decisions and Votes The Commission voted to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding a request for alternative compliance at 346 East Sonley Drive, the Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to defer the request until the following month. This decision allows the property owner and their landscape professional time to revise the planting plan based on the Commission’s feedback. Additionally, the Commission voted 5-2 to continue holding meetings virtually rather than switching to in-person sessions. The motion to continue with virtual meetings passed after a roll call vote, with two members voting against the motion.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the alternative compliance request for 346 East Sonley Drive, where staff presented a plan to remediate a tree removal violation. The discussion focused on the suitability of proposed tree species for the site’s southern exposure and slope stability. Commissioner Karen McNeil expressed strong concern that the proposal excluded oaks, stating, "I feel pretty strongly that leaving out oaks from the replanting proposal after several mature oaks were removed doesn't really meet that standard. Oaks are a keystone species... I would really like to see oaks included in the replanting proposal." Commissioner Sharon Summerall also voiced concerns about the plan, noting, "I personally won't recommend with this planting plan, it to be approved. I would like to see a wider range of planting, more underbrush planting to hold up this steep part of this slope." The City Arborist, Mark Foster, provided technical context, observing that many proposed species were better suited for north or east-facing exposures and that oaks might not grow fast enough to compete with shade-intolerant species like poplars.

Staff also presented reports on routine tree removals, holiday decorations, and the status of the Urban Forester hiring process, which is currently with Human Resources. The Tree Protection Ordinance report noted that funds have been collected but not yet spent. Updates from working groups covered the revision of Chapter 20 (Hazard Tree Assessment), budgeting for a tree inventory and urban forest master plan, and potential uses for fee-in-lieu funds, including land acquisition. The Chair provided an update on the city-wide effort to realign boards and commissions, noting that a survey of members is expected soon. Additionally, the Chair noted that the Duke Energy Rankin Street Land Swap project is currently on hold following public outcry, with community meetings tentatively scheduled for November or December.

Community Input During the public comment period, a public commenter spoke regarding a topic unrelated to urban forestry, discussing claims of "legal name fraud" and "birth certificate fraud." Commissioner Cecil Bothwell responded by stating, "It has no relevance whatsoever to urban forestry." The Chair then ended the commenter's time.

Follow-ups The Commission deferred the alternative compliance request for 346 East Sonley Drive, with the applicant and their landscape designer expected to revise the planting plan to address the Commission’s recommendations regarding species diversity and erosion control before returning to the Commission next month. Staff confirmed they will be in touch regarding the deadline for the revised plan. The Chair agreed to coordinate with city staff to get traction on the revision of Chapter 20 and the finalization of amendments to tree canopy preservation laws. The Chair also stated she would ask for an update on the status of tree planting standards from the Development Services Department. Finally, the group agreed to target January 2023 for the annual retreat, with suggestions to include discussions on invasive species management and a deep dive into changes to Ordinance 719.1 or 719.3.

Impact These decisions impact residents by maintaining the Commission’s focus on appropriate tree species for local conditions, particularly on slopes and in southern exposures, which is critical for erosion control and long-term tree health. The decision to continue with virtual meetings aims to balance environmental benefits, such as reduced driving, with accessibility and equity concerns, while acknowledging the value of in-person interaction. The deferral of the Sonley Drive request ensures that the replanting plan is revised to better suit the site’s specific ecological needs before approval.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches