Skip to main content
  • 1 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: September 27, 2022

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on September 27, 2022, to address rising crime statistics, review contract amendments, and discuss new pilot programs. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of an addendum to the Axon contract, a presentation on violent crime data, and an overview of a proposed Community Responder Pilot Program. The meeting concluded with a review of the committee’s work plan for the coming months.

Key Decisions The committee took two formal votes during the session. First, the committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting, with all three voting members casting "Aye" votes. Second, the committee voted unanimously to move the Axon contract addendum forward to the full council for approval. This addendum corrects an error in the existing five-year contract for body-worn cameras, tasers, and in-car cameras, which had omitted annual fees for storage, warranties, and licensing.

Discussion Highlights Police Chief David Zak presented data indicating a sharp year-to-date increase in violent crime, driven primarily by a 44% increase in aggravated assaults and a 50% increase in armed robberies. He outlined APD’s strategies to address these trends, including the deployment of an "Impact Team" for gun violence, forensic investments, and recruitment efforts. Chief Zak stated, "Although violent crime trends are discouraging, APD is committed to ensuring Asheville is a safe place to live, do business, shop, recreate, and visit... To effectively address increasing crime in our community, we must reimagine and assume public safety as a responsibility of every sector of our community."

Fire Chief Scott Burnett presented a proposed multidisciplinary Community Responder Pilot Program designed to address long-term needs for individuals experiencing behavioral health crises, addiction, or unsheltered status. Chief Burnett noted, "Currently, the City of Asheville’s resources are focused on the short-term... We don’t have a lot of ability or capability to address long-term care options... We are looking at developing a multidisciplinary community responder pilot program... to provide not only the short-term response... but the long-term solutions." Councilwoman Kim Roney raised concerns about potential service duplication, asking, "I am curious about duplicating services while we’re understaffed... What is the cost to Asheville and Buncombe taxpayers if we risk duplicating something like this again?"

Community Input During opening and closing public comment periods, residents expressed significant concern over rising violent crime, fentanyl overdoses, and safety in downtown Asheville. Multiple commenters cited personal experiences with muggings, needle litter, and fear of walking in various neighborhoods, including Beaver Dam, North Asheville, South Asheville, and the East Side. Several residents specifically requested the removal of Councilwoman Kim Roney from the committee, arguing that her voting history regarding police funding and federal grants hindered public safety. Other commenters presented data on fentanyl-related emergency room treatments and field deaths, urging that these be included in public safety strategy discussions, while others called for better management of transient populations and encampments. No member of the committee responded to these specific requests for removal, safety anecdotes, or data points during the recorded transcript.

Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith stated she would support staff providing direction to research two unfunded ARPA (American Rescue Plan Act) applications—one for a transit center and one for the downtown CBD—potentially bringing them to a future Public Safety Committee meeting. Fire Chief Scott Burnett stated that the city will likely return to the committee in November to provide an update on the progress of the Community Responder Pilot Program. Staff indicated that detailed cost comparisons regarding the responder program might be available in January or February, though they would plan to provide additional information in November. Additionally, Councilwoman Roney requested that the January agenda item for "violence interruption" be explicitly expanded to include "youth initiatives" and mentorship programming, and she requested a six-month budget update specific to public safety to assess deficits, surpluses, and staffing costs. City Manager Deborah Campbell noted that full council receives quarterly budget updates but stated she would consider how to provide public-safety-specific information to this committee.

Impact This meeting highlights the city's response to a significant rise in violent crime and the ongoing challenge of balancing acute police response with long-term community support services. The decision to move the Axon contract addendum to full council ensures that the city can correct billing errors in its existing technology contracts. The proposed Community Responder Pilot Program represents a shift toward addressing the root causes of certain 911 calls, such as behavioral health crises, rather than relying solely on law enforcement. The upcoming follow-ups, including the November update on the responder pilot and the research into ARPA funding, will determine how the city allocates resources to address both immediate safety concerns and long-term infrastructure needs.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches