Governance Committee
September 13, 2022 at 2:35 PM
- 1 h 7 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Governance Committee Meeting Recap: September 13, 2022
The City of Asheville Governance Committee held a virtual meeting on September 13, 2022, to address procedural updates, committee structure, and environmental policy. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a proposed amendment to council rules regarding remote attendance, a review of the City Council’s committee structure, and a phased approach to reducing single-use plastics.
Key Decisions The committee took three formal votes during the session. First, the committee approved the minutes from the June meeting via a roll call vote, with Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Wessler, and Mayor Manheimer voting "Aye." Second, the committee voted to recommend that the full City Council adopt a resolution amending the rules of procedure to include a remote attendance provision. This motion was seconded and passed with "Aye" votes from Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Whistler, and Mayor Manheimer. Third, the committee voted to recommend the phased rollout of the plastic reduction ordinance as proposed by staff, with "Aye" votes from Councilwoman Roney, Councilwoman Wessler, and Mayor Manheimer.
Remote Attendance and Committee Structure City Attorney Brad Branham presented the remote attendance amendment, noting it is necessary because the state of emergency that previously authorized virtual meetings has been lifted. He clarified that while council committees can meet fully remotely, full City Council meetings must be in person, with remote participation allowed only for discussion—not voting or quorum—unless a local emergency is declared.
Staff also presented a proposal to revise the scope and composition of City Council committees, which have not been updated since 2006, to better align with current strategic priorities. Councilwoman Gwen Whistler suggested incorporating a requirement for council committees to formally review their alignment with strategic priorities annually, rather than waiting a decade for updates. Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that the public might perceive these changes as tied to the city’s organizational restructure and suggested waiting until the next Governance Committee meeting in October to allow for more community engagement and communication.
Plastic Reduction Ordinance The Office of Sustainability presented a phased approach to reducing single-use plastics, recommending a near-term prohibition on plastic bags for curbside leaf collection and further public engagement for a broader ordinance in the future. Sustainability Director Bridget Perrin explained that the phased approach is recommended because the department currently lacks the staff capacity to conduct the extensive public engagement required for a full single-use plastic ban without deprioritizing other major projects, such as the Municipal Climate Action Plan. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that the committee would move the ordinance forward as staff recommended, allowing the full council to hear more input and determine how to address capacity issues to potentially narrow the timeline for the first phase.
Community Input Public comment was held regarding the Plastic Reduction Ordinance. A public commenter representing a riverkeeper organization and a coalition urged the city not to let "perfect be the enemy of good," emphasizing the declared climate emergency and stating that partners are willing to help with implementation on a faster timeline. A resident from the Suwannee NOAA area thanked the council for considering the ordinance, noting that plastic pollution is extensive in local rivers and increasing in microplastic loads. A public commenter from a nonprofit organization involved in the "Plastic Free WNC" coalition argued that the proposed phased approach was "reinventing the wheel" because the coalition had already conducted extensive research and business collaboration, requesting a more aggressive timeline and stating that waiting two years was too long. Finally, a public commenter representing the North Carolina Retail Merchants Association raised legal concerns, stating that North Carolina is a "Dillon rule" state and that local ordinances banning plastic bags or foodware may violate the North Carolina Constitution and General Statutes, warning that such measures could increase food prices. No specific member replied directly to these comments during the recorded segment.
Follow-Ups and Next Steps Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood stated that staff will bring the feedback received from the Governance Committee back to a future Governance Committee meeting. The goal is to have the full City Council vote on the committee structure changes in advance of December, so the Mayor can appoint new council members to the revised committees after the November election. Additionally, the committee directed staff to bring the phased plastic reduction ordinance to the full City Council at the next meeting for discussion and direction.
Meeting Video & Transcript