Governance Committee - Part 2 of 2
June 14, 2022 at 1:21 PM
- 1 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Governance Committee Meeting Recap: June 14, 2022
The City of Asheville Governance Committee met on June 14, 2022, to review administrative items and discuss a proposed community-driven Open Meetings Policy. The primary focus of the session was improving accessibility, transparency, and public engagement in city government meetings. The committee reviewed a framework presented by Patrick Conant of Code for Asheville, which aims to standardize how public bodies provide information, manage meeting processes, and facilitate public participation.
Key Decisions The only formal vote taken during the meeting was the approval of the minutes from the April 12, 2022 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and a roll call vote was conducted. Councilwoman Remy, Councilwoman Bessler, and the Chair all voted "Aye," resulting in the unanimous approval of the minutes. No votes were taken on the Open Meetings Policy or any other substantive motions. While a council member recommended that the policy presentation be placed on a future City Council agenda, the Chair noted that formal agenda slots are typically reserved for task forces or committees and suggested that staff’s upcoming presentation might clarify overlaps with existing work. No decision was made to authorize the full Council presentation at this time.
Discussion Highlights Patrick Conant presented the Open Meetings Policy framework, emphasizing that it serves as a template to ensure consistency across all local government boards and commissions. He highlighted three key areas: ensuring basic information is accessible via a single searchable resource, standardizing the publication of agendas and documents, and creating multiple avenues for public input, including live call-in options. Conant stated, "We believe the government works best when they build with, not for an informed and engaged community."
Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed gratitude for the policy work and shared her experience serving with blind community members, noting that accessibility issues range from meeting notices to document availability. She cited a specific recent difficulty finding the planning and zoning meeting archive, stating, "This week I attempted to find the planning and zoning meeting archive. It wasn't on the city's YouTube page... And then I found it underneath the planning and zoning documents in a new location that I had never seen before." The Chair responded by noting that while some aspects of the policy are already implemented for City Council meetings, they may not apply to subcommittees or other boards. The Chair also raised concerns about staff capacity and asked if the presenter had reviewed the overlap between the proposed policy and the City’s ARPA-funded community engagement initiatives.
Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, provided an update on the City’s existing accessibility efforts. She emphasized the importance of a collaborative process, stating, "I think it's really important that residents have a voice and we do it in a collaborative process, not just reporting issues, but actually looking at how are our meetings working today, who's here, who's missing, and how do we make sure these meetings are as accessible as possible for everyone in Asheville." A council member also spoke on the need for centralization, suggesting, "If instead of these columns where everything is divided, if a web page was a central location... it would work like a hub... I think we might be needing to shift from thinking to columns to a hub where everything points in one space."
Community Input Three members of the public spoke during the general public comment period, all expressing support for the Open Meetings Policy. A resident of Shiloh urged the committee to recommend that City Council adopt a robust policy, arguing that "opaque government... is tyranny" and that a healthy democracy requires ongoing, accessible participation. A co-organizer of Code for Asheville emphasized that the policy adds a necessary commitment to consistency and requested that the committee allow the policy to be presented for consideration by the full City Council rather than just under public comment. A member of Faith for Justice Asheville criticized the current "staff-driven" approach as undemocratic, arguing that residents should be co-creating solutions. This commenter disagreed with the Chair’s earlier statement that Code for Asheville could not present outside of public comment, asserting that the Mayor/Committee has the power to facilitate such a presentation. No specific member responded directly to any of these comments before the Chair adjourned the meeting.
Follow-ups Staff provided several specific commitments regarding ongoing projects. In response to a question about reporting on ARPA-funded projects, a staff member stated that the City is currently pulling together an organizational work plan and committed to identifying feedback mechanisms and reporting structures within the next month, promising to provide an update at the next Governance Committee meeting. Dawa Hitch reported that the City has implemented automatic notifications to content editors if pages have not been reviewed within 60 days, with the next milestone for a deeper website audit scheduled for September. She also stated that the invitation to participate in the "Your Voice, Your Choice" engagement hub will go out by the end of the week. Additionally, Hitch outlined a two-year timeline for the ARPA Inclusive and Accessible Government Project, noting that the first six months will focus on scoping and hiring, including temporary full-time positions for sign language interpretation and Spanish/Russian social media management, as well as upfitting five community spaces for hybrid meetings.
Impact This meeting highlights the City’s ongoing efforts to modernize and improve how it engages with residents. The discussion centered on the tension between existing staff-driven initiatives and community-driven proposals for standardized transparency. By committing to specific timelines for ARPA reporting and website audits, staff indicated that infrastructure improvements are underway. The debate over whether to formally present the Open Meetings Policy to the full Council remains unresolved, leaving the policy in a pending state while staff continues to work on integrating accessibility goals with current projects.
Meeting Video & Transcript