Skip to main content
  • 1 h 40 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On September 6, 2022, the City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened to address a range of operational, policy, and budgetary issues. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates on staff hiring and citywide realignment efforts, and detailed discussions regarding tree removal protocols, particularly in the context of a recent incident on Merriman Avenue. The meeting also featured updates from various working groups focused on ordinance revisions, budget requests, and the development of an Urban Forest Master Plan.

Key Decisions

The Commission’s primary formal action was the approval of the minutes from the July meeting. A motion was made and seconded, followed by a roll call vote in which all voting members voted "Aye," resulting in the unanimous approval of the minutes. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was seconded and put to a roll call vote. While the transcript records "Aye" votes from several members, it does not explicitly state the final tally or confirm if the motion passed, though the chair ended the meeting. No other formal votes or decisions were recorded during the session.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the failure of a "Treasured Tree" on Merriman Avenue (US 25), highlighting the complexities of coordinating between the City, NCDOT, and private property owners. City Arborist Mark Foster noted that he has had "essentially one functional tree crew for the last three years," resulting in a high-priority work queue that is "two years deep." Public Works Streets Division Manager Chad Bandy emphasized the timing of the incident, stating, "Thank goodness it was 3:00 a.m. on Merriman Avenue, not 3:00 p.m., which would have been tragic." Vice Chair Dawn Chavez clarified that the treasured trees program "doesn't offer any legal protection," adding that if a tree needs to come down, "whether or not it has a plaque on it, it needs to come down."

Regarding policy, the Commission discussed revisions to Chapter 20 (Tree Removal), including the adoption of ANSI A300 standards for risk assessment. Commission Member Ed Macy encouraged the city to adopt ANSI A300 Part 9 as a methodology for determining hazard, calling it a "very effective protocol." Commission Member Cecil Bothwell shared a personal perspective on the difficulty of these decisions, noting he is "hung on that right now" regarding whether to save or cut a threatened walnut tree on his own property. Commission Member Sharon Summerall suggested the need for a "social media guru" to help the public understand that incidents are being handled. Commission Member Patrick Gilbert questioned the holdup on Chapter 20, noting that staff from Public Works and DSD had given the "green light" on revisions to push them forward to the City Council. City Council Liaison Kim Roney responded that while she would carry a recommendation to the full council, she "hasn't yet heard a formal recommendation made."

Other topics included an update on the hiring of a permanent Urban Forester, with staff Nancy Watford and Chris Collins working on the position description. The Commission also reviewed the Tree Protection Ordinance, noting that Central Business District projects have not yet reached the final permitting stage required for fee assessment. Additionally, the Commission discussed a steep slope tree removal violation at Elk Mountain, with Zoning Supervisor Ricky stating, "You can't force a compliance by lying to us on paper... we're going to say 10 feet because it's a 28 percent slope."

Community Input

A public commenter joined the line to monitor an agenda item but did not provide spoken public comment. The staff member closed the line, and no specific reply was given by members or staff as no comment was made.

Follow-ups

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:

  • Policy Working Group: Patrick Gilbert suggested the group work with city staff to develop protocols for tree removal on state roads and multiple-ownership situations, a path the Chair confirmed.
  • Urban Forester Hiring: Staff Nancy Watford agreed to share the position announcement with the Commission once it is ready, aiming to post the position by the end of the month.
  • Steep Slope Review: Zoning Supervisor Ricky agreed to work with Nancy Watford to refine a checklist for steep slope plan reviews, incorporating grading zone requirements and critical root zone overlays. He also offered to provide education to community groups regarding tree removal permits.
  • Budget Request Working Group: Zoe Boyle volunteered to join the group in place of Patrick Gilbert, while Cecil Bothwell confirmed he is returning to the group. The group agreed to focus on the Urban Forest Master Plan, tree inventory, and care/maintenance of existing trees.
  • Fee-in-Lieu Framework: The Chair and the working group (Zoe Boyle, Ed Macy) agreed to develop a framework for decision-making regarding the use of fee-in-lieu funds.
  • Remote Meeting Policy: The Commission will wait for the City Council’s vote later in the month. Once the Council decides, the Commission will vote on whether to hold meetings remotely or in person for the next year.
  • New Member Recruitment: The Chair and Dawn Chavez will review applications for the open commission seat, looking for candidates with semi-professional credentials in urban forestry.

Impact

This meeting highlights the ongoing strain on the city’s urban forestry resources, with staff reporting a two-year backlog of high-priority work due to limited crew capacity. The discussion on the Merriman Avenue incident underscores the challenges of managing tree safety on state roads and the lack of legal protection for designated "Treasured Trees." The progression of the Chapter 20 tree removal ordinance, including the potential adoption of ANSI A300 standards, is significant for residents as it aims to standardize how hazard trees are assessed and removed. Additionally, the focus on developing a framework for fee-in-lieu funds and an Urban Forest Master Plan indicates an effort to create more structured funding and long-term planning for the city's tree canopy, which is essential for maintaining the health and safety of public trees.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches