Human Relations Commission
July 21, 2022 at 5:30 PM
- 1 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: July 21, 2022
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened on July 21, 2022, to address structural updates, procedural rules, and ongoing working group initiatives. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the June 16, 2022 session, which passed unanimously. The primary focus of the agenda was the revision of the commission’s rules of procedure and updates on city-wide advisory board realignment efforts.
A significant decision was made regarding the commission’s membership criteria. The body voted 5-2 to remove specific numerical quotas for racial and demographic representation from its rules of procedure. The motion, moved by the Chair and seconded by Commissioner Chandler, was approved with Commissioners Venable and Harold voting against. The Chair explained that removing the numerical barriers is an equitable act that facilitates inclusion, while City Attorney Brad Branham noted that the changes would ensure the commission remains in compliance with legal standards regarding racial quotas.
Staff provided updates on the city-wide realignment of advisory boards, noting that a working group has been formed to evaluate the current structure. A survey regarding board structures is scheduled to be sent to all board and commission members the week of August 1. Additionally, staff shared an update on the Reparations Commission, clarifying that its current focus is on education and defining what reparations mean for Asheville, rather than discussing or voting on a reparations tax. Staff also reported on the Housing working group’s draft recommendation to add "source of income" to the city’s non-discrimination ordinance, which would allow residents to file complaints if denied rental housing due to the use of vouchers or child support.
The commission also discussed a proposed change to its regular meeting schedule, moving from the third Thursday to the second Monday at 5:30 PM. After reviewing scheduling conflicts among commissioners and staff, the group decided to keep meetings on their current day (Thursday) for the time being. To ensure continued staff support, the Director of Equity and Inclusion agreed to substitute for the equity consultant at monthly meetings until the consultant completes their doctoral program.
No public comments were recorded during the meeting, as the chair confirmed there was no one in the speaker queue.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session. Staff committed to sending a link to the Reparations Commission’s webpage and meeting videos to commission members for community sharing. Staff also agreed to provide full notes from previous retreats to new members to assist with working group onboarding. The Housing working group stated they will share their draft recommendation regarding "source of income" in advance of the next meeting for discussion. Furthermore, staff suggested providing an overview of the city’s complaint response process at a future meeting, which the Chair noted as an item for the next agenda. Councilwoman Kim Roney indicated that once the commission finalizes recommendations, such as the rules of procedure changes, she will include them in her report to the full City Council.
These decisions impact residents by refining how the commission operates and how it addresses local discrimination. The removal of numerical quotas aims to broaden the diversity of the commission’s membership, while the potential addition of "source of income" protections to the housing ordinance could provide a local mechanism for tracking and addressing rental discrimination against voucher holders.
Meeting Video & Transcript