Skip to main content
  • 1 h 22 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville met on June 16, 2022, to review recent minutes, receive staff updates, and discuss significant changes to the city’s advisory board structure. The agenda included the approval of previous records, a review of proposed changes to the Commission’s rules of procedure, and a discussion regarding the City’s plan to restructure community advisory boards.

Key Decisions

The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the April 21, 2022 meeting. Regarding the proposed changes to the Rules of Procedure, specifically the removal of specific numerical quotas for membership, no final vote was recorded. During the roll call, one member voted "No" and another requested to abstain. Consequently, the Chair removed the motion from the floor and tabled the item for the next meeting to allow new members time to review the changes and for staff to investigate legal implications. Additionally, the Commission agreed to form a working group to develop a recommendation to City Council regarding the restructuring of community advisory boards; however, no formal vote was taken to adopt a specific recommendation at this meeting.

Discussion Highlights

Staff provided updates on the Office of Equity and Inclusion’s new monthly newsletter, "Let’s Talk Equity," and confirmed that City Council voted to appoint four new members to the Commission: Lena Smith, Ashley Wilberding, Christopher Boyd, and Alma Atkins. Staff also outlined the upcoming schedule for the Community Reparations Commission, noting that July meetings will focus on impact areas such as criminal justice, economic development, education, housing, and health and wellness.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposed removal of numerical quotas in the Rules of Procedure. A staff member (legal representative) stated, "quotas are not committed within government practice, state or federally, as it is written with the number, those are not enforceable. So it's as if you're reading them without the numbers." The Chair argued against specific numbers, stating, "by putting in the numbers... it's like adding boxes... instead of organically allowing the people who want to be here to be here... why are we putting limitations on ourselves and on the commission that represents our voices in this community?" In contrast, a Commissioner expressed concern that removing the numbers might lead to a lack of Black representation, stating, "I am concerned going back once again, looking at how it's always been hard to recruit black people specifically... it just feels like business as usual... I'm afraid that those numbers of that quota that's there goes away it's not going to be like that anymore."

The Commission also discussed the City’s plan to restructure and potentially disband over 20 community advisory boards, including the HRCA, into four new advisory boards. A Commissioner presented the concern that the City is moving "hastily" to disband boards, stating, "the concern is making sure that all voices are heard especially the community we want to make sure that the city kind of looks at this in some sort of a shared decision-making process rather than jumping hastily into making a decision for us than making a decision with us." Staff (Brenda Mills) clarified, "We have slowed down. The pilot is supposed to start this month... ultimately the vote is not staff. It is city council." She also noted that the four proposed groups are "not set in stone" and that the HRCA could potentially continue as a "committee" under the new structure. Council Liaison Kim Roney advised members on engaging with City Council, noting, "It is recommended... that not just hit reply all so that all the commission members get it, but you can certainly forward that directly to the council member when you reach out."

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to investigate the feasibility of using diversity percentages (e.g., 70%) in the Rules of Procedure as an alternative to specific numerical quotas. Council Liaison Kim Roney suggested recirculating the original recommendations from the Blue Ribbon Commission to help new members understand the history of the membership numbers. The Commission agreed to establish a working group within the Intergovernmental Relations committee to draft a recommendation to City Council regarding the board restructuring pilot, with staff agreeing to send links to the project page and recent presentations to help members prepare. The Chair agreed to follow up with the member responsible for the sanctuary campaign recommendation to see if it is ready for a vote at the next meeting. Additionally, the Chair agreed to reach out to City Council to revisit a previous recommendation regarding protections for the health system community during inclement weather/extreme heat, as it had not yet been heard by Council. Staff from the Office of Equity and Inclusion stated they are working on uploading a tutorial video to the city website explaining how to file a complaint under the non-discrimination ordinance.

Impact

This meeting addressed the future structure of the Human Relations Commission and its relationship with the City’s broader advisory board system. The decision to table the Rules of Procedure changes ensures that new members have time to review the implications of removing numerical quotas before a final vote is taken. The formation of a working group to advise City Council on board restructuring provides a mechanism for the Commission to influence how community advisory boards are organized, potentially affecting how residents engage with city government on equity and inclusion issues.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches