Skip to main content
  • 1 h 48 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: May 19, 2022

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee convened on May 19, 2022, to address meeting logistics, review integrated transportation plans, and conduct informal design reviews for two local projects. The session focused on streamlining the committee’s process and evaluating the design merits of developments in the downtown and river district areas.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the April 22, 2022 meeting. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the Greenway, ADA, and Pedestrian (GAP) Master Plans for inclusion in the standard specifications and details manual. The committee also found that the GAP project meets the intent of the river district design review guidelines. No formal votes were taken on the two informal design review items discussed later in the meeting.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing the length of recent sessions, which had extended to three and a half hours. Members debated the balance between informal and formal reviews, with one member emphasizing the need for applicants to complete preliminary work before presenting to the committee, stating, "I just feel like you have to be willing to do a certain amount of work before it comes to us, not just give us a blank box and say, Well, where should we do here?"

Staff from the Transportation Department presented the GAP plans, which are scheduled to go to City Council for adoption in July. The presentation covered prioritization methodologies, new greenway typologies, and design guidelines. A staff member noted the funding landscape, stating, "For greenways, we have zero recurring funds... The MPO [Metropolitan Planning Organization] is the best partner funding partner because they have so much money that’s dedicated strictly to transportation."

The committee conducted an informal design review for Redwood Commons at 21 Governor’s View Road. The architect presented updates to the building’s massing, roofline, and materials. The committee confirmed that the presentation satisfied the condition of the project’s conditional zoning approval. One member commented on the material changes, stating, "I personally am really glad you changed to brick from the stone. I think that was a really, really good move."

The final agenda item was the fourth iteration of the Create Project at 72 Broadway. The discussion focused on the building’s material palette, massing logic, and contextual views. One member expressed strong reservations about the design, stating, "This is my least favorite building I’ve ever seen you do... I just find it to be pretty, again, I love some of the things you’ve done. It’s my least favorite of yours." Another member argued against changing the central feature from brick, noting, "I don’t personally think that’s a good move [changing it from brick] because I think that centerpiece could be the piece that nods to the traditional architecture around this building." A third member emphasized the need for better context, stating, "We need to see what this really looks like in the larger context... This is a prominent site... You have to put the muscle behind it in order to get, you know, study it thoroughly and make sure that you’ve got the right thing."

Community Input No members of the public spoke during the general public comment period or on any specific agenda items. Staff noted that two email comments had been received regarding the Create Project, both related to the design.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to adjust the online meeting invite to start at 12:00 PM to allow for a 30-minute informal pre-meeting discussion before the official 12:30 PM start. Staff also agreed to perform a time check at 2:00 PM to allow members to leave if they wish, with the option to submit comments via email later. Staff confirmed that reviewing the design guidelines is on their list of tasks to help streamline future reviews. For the Redwood Commons project, staff will note in the project file that the informal review condition was satisfied. For the Create Project, the architect stated they would contact staff to discuss next steps and would prepare a more detailed presentation, including site context views, for the formal review at the next meeting.

Impact These decisions and discussions impact residents by establishing a clearer process for design reviews and advancing the city’s long-term transportation planning. The approval of the GAP plans supports the development of greenways, accessible routes, and pedestrian infrastructure, which are scheduled for City Council adoption in July. The feedback provided on the Redwood Commons and Create Project will guide the architects as they refine their designs, with the Create Project returning for a formal review at a future meeting.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches