Design Review Committee
March 17, 2022 at 12:30 PM
- 2 h 12 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: March 17, 2022
The City of Asheville Design Review Committee (DRC) convened on March 17, 2022, to conduct administrative business and review three development projects. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the February 17, 2022 meeting, which passed unanimously. The committee also elected new leadership for the term, with Robin Raines unanimously elected as Chair and Jeremy Goldstein unanimously elected as Vice Chair. Chair Robin Raines noted that the committee’s primary function is to provide design review for projects located in the city’s three designated design review areas: downtown, the riverfront, and the new hotel overlay zoning districts.
The first project reviewed was Swannanoa Greenway Segment 1, a formal review of a 0.84-mile greenway along the Swannanoa River. Staff presented the project as part of the larger Fontaflora Trail system, noting that a feasibility study had identified this segment as a priority. Following public comment, the committee voted unanimously to support the greenway effort and the submitted designs. A public commenter expressed concern via email about pedestrian access at the Wood Avenue connection, noting the lack of a safe crossing at the nearby intersection with South Tunnel Road. The Chair read the comment, but no member or staff member responded to it before the committee proceeded to vote. During the discussion, a committee member who identified herself as a landscape architect on the Riverfront Commission urged the team to use the project as an opportunity to extend Asheville’s design identity into the commercial/suburban area with creative materials and signage.
The committee then conducted an informal review of 31 Artful Way, a proposed 61-unit apartment building with a hotel component and parking structure in the River Arts District. Three members—Steven Lee Johnson, Jeremy Goldstein, and Christina Roush—recused themselves from the review due to conflicts of interest. No formal vote was taken. A public commenter submitted an email requesting that the driveway be located on Artful Way and expressing concern that there was "too much parking." In response, member Steven Lee Johnson stated that the access location was forced by site conditions and that the parking was required. Laura Hudson, the architect, added that she would like to see parking minimums go away to force other urban design options. The design team agreed to provide additional views and refine details, including the metal panel gradient and stair tower detailing, before a future formal review.
The final item was an informal review of 21 Governors View Road, a proposed 70-unit affordable senior living facility near the Swannanoa River Road. No formal vote was taken. A public commenter raised several concerns, arguing that using the adjacent Aldi store intersection as the primary access point was more logical than using the narrow Governor’s View Road, which they argued would be damaged by construction. The presenter explained that using the adjacent property was complicated by traffic and floodway constraints, stating that Governor’s View is the "simplest access that we can get." The commenter also criticized the building’s scale, calling it a "powering behemoth" that was "totally out of character," and asked about sustainability features like green roofs or solar panels. The presenter clarified that the increase to a four-story, 70-unit design resulted from city support to explore a larger building, and that the project will pursue an "Energy Star for Multifamily" rating, though specific features like solar panels depend on funding.
Regarding follow-ups, the architect for 31 Artful Way, Laura Hudson, agreed to provide a view of the building from the Clingman Avenue extension at the next meeting and to consider feedback on materials and detailing. For 21 Governors View Road, architect Aaron Bowman agreed to study suggestions regarding the roof massing, stair tower cutouts, entry prominence, and material choices. He also acknowledged the concern about pedestrian connectivity to the Swannanoa Greenway. Additionally, the presenter for 21 Governors View Road asked for guidance on submission requirements for the upcoming formal design review, planning to submit for the April meeting. A committee member responded that they would discuss the best way forward offline.
These reviews are significant for residents as they shape the physical development of key areas in Asheville, including the riverfront and the River Arts District. The committee’s feedback on the affordable senior housing project addresses community concerns about scale and access in a residential neighborhood, while the support for the Swannanoa Greenway reinforces the city’s investment in public trail infrastructure. The informal reviews for the Artful Way and Governors View Road projects indicate that further design refinement is expected before formal approval can be sought.
Meeting Video & Transcript