Skip to main content
  • 2 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: April 5, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission held a virtual meeting on April 5, 2022, to review ongoing tree management projects, proposed changes to city landscaping standards, and updates on various working groups. The meeting addressed the status of the Vermont Avenue sidewalk project, the revision of the outdated tree ordinance, and the allocation of fee-and-lieu funds for land preservation.

Key Decisions The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting. In a significant decision regarding land preservation, the commission voted unanimously to accept a recommendation to use fee-and-lieu funds to acquire the property at 11 Collier Avenue in the South Slope neighborhood for permanent preservation. This recommendation, drafted by the Fee and Lieu Working Group, will be submitted to City Council via their liaison. Additionally, the commission voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with an attorney, as permitted by North Carolina state law.

Discussion Highlights Staff from Capital Projects provided an update on the Vermont Avenue sidewalk project, noting that a field walk conducted on March 30 reassessed the health of trees between Haywood Road and just south of Only Road. The assessment, which categorizes trees as keep, remove, or evaluate further, is not yet finalized. The Chair expressed appreciation for the collaboration on this project, stating, "In my experience and time here, this has so far just been a really pleasant process... I really, really appreciate that."

A major point of discussion involved the Policy Working Group’s effort to revise Chapter 20, the city’s outdated tree ordinance. Staff informed the commission that the Development Services Department lacks the capacity to take on the revision, explaining that the commission must make a formal recommendation to City Council to instruct the City Manager to allocate capacity. This news caused significant frustration among members. One member stated, "I'm pretty upset about this... I wish we were told a year ago before we put all this work into it that our work was for naught." Another member added, "I'm extremely irritated about it... It is a good, viable rewrite that doesn't need any editing at all... I'm extremely annoyed." The Assistant City Manager responded, "I would rather say let's not drop it... I'd still like to kind of keep it on the radar because there has been a lot of energy put into it... I just need us to step back and maybe have a conversation after this meeting with the subcommittee to talk about timing."

Staff from Planning and Urban Design presented proposed changes to citywide landscaping standards, including establishing a minimum uncompacted soil volume requirement, implementing third-party inspections, and reducing required parking lot trees from one per 1,500 square feet to one per 3,000 square feet to allow for greater soil volume. The City Arborist reported on recent storm damage and discussed treating Emerald Ash Borer via soil drenching rather than injection, noting that while injections are costlier, soil drenching is effective and more affordable for the city’s budget. He remarked, "I'm sorry if I come across as so grouchy as a tree lover here, but it's kind of like being a cop, my interactions with trees. I too often encounter them behaving badly rather than behaving well."

The commission also reviewed a draft of updated rules and procedures. When a member questioned a clause stating that a non-vote is counted as an affirmative vote, staff clarified that this mirrors North Carolina state law for public bodies, which does not allow for abstentions unless a member is recused. The commission agreed to keep this provision as written. Additionally, a member proposed revisiting the steep slope ordinance to better protect trees and improve stormwater management, citing a recent case in East Asheville where trees were cut on a steep slope without a permit. The commission agreed to add this topic to the agenda for an upcoming meeting with staff.

Follow-ups Staff from Capital Projects agreed to finalize the tree assessment for the Vermont Avenue project and request help from the commission with the replanting plan and canopy calculations. Staff from Planning and Urban Design agreed to meet with other cities that have implemented minimum soil volume standards to address concerns about costs and feasibility. Staff from Development Services agreed to meet with the Policy Working Group to discuss the process and timing for the Chapter 20 revision. The Commission Chair agreed to follow up with Duke Energy to encourage their participation in future meetings regarding ongoing complaints about tree trimming. Commission members agreed to review the draft Rules and Procedures document and provide comments before the next meeting, and to continue engaging with City Council members regarding Urban Forestry Master Plan funding.

Impact These discussions highlight the commission's role in balancing urban development with tree preservation. The decision to acquire the 11 Collier Avenue parcel ensures permanent protection for a forested area in the South Slope neighborhood. The proposed changes to landscaping standards aim to improve tree survival rates in urban areas by addressing issues like compacted soils and poor installation processes. The ongoing dialogue regarding the Chapter 20 revision underscores the importance of clear communication between the commission and city staff regarding resource allocation for updating outdated regulations.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches