Skip to main content

Urban Forestry Commission

March 1, 2022 at 1:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Feb 22 meetingNext: Apr 5 meeting
  • 1 h 57 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission held a hybrid virtual and in-person meeting on March 1, 2022. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, reviews of alternative compliance requests for development projects, a presentation from the City’s Office of Data and Performance, staff reports on urban forestry metrics, and a formal resolution regarding the proposed restructuring of city boards and commissions.

Key Decisions

The Commission approved the minutes from the February meeting by a unanimous vote of 7 ayes. Regarding development applications, the Commission unanimously approved (7 ayes) an alternative compliance request for 700 Hendersonville Road, accepting the applicant’s exception to street tree and planting strip width requirements due to existing utilities and building constraints. For the 635 Patton Avenue project (Asheville Food Pod), the Commission voted unanimously (7 ayes) to table the item until the next month. This decision allows the applicant to return with a revised plan that resolves concerns regarding tree species selection and clearance from high-voltage transmission lines.

The Commission also voted unanimously (7 ayes) to adopt a resolution opposing the City Council’s proposal to eliminate the Urban Forestry Commission and consolidate boards into four new bodies. The resolution states that the Commission opposes the proposal as currently written and urges the City Council to reject it. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to adjourn.

Discussion Highlights

During the discussion of the 635 Patton Avenue project, Commission members expressed concern about the long-term survival of proposed flowering trees, such as Sargent cherries and redbuds, in a harsh urban environment. Ed Gilbert noted that flowering ornamentals often come with significant maintenance issues and that redbuds have been underperformers recently. Sharon Summerall added that the recommended species list needs work, preferring trees that survive without constant care. The City Arborist confirmed that the overhead wires near the proposed planting areas are high-voltage, making large trees unsafe in that location.

In the debate over the board restructuring resolution, Cecil Bothwell argued that consolidating 200 volunteers into four groups would result in a lack of time and attention, describing the proposal as "wrongheaded" and driven by development interests. Ed Gilbert suggested adding language to clarify that the Commission opposes the proposal only "as currently proposed," leaving room for other forms of restructuring. Amy Smith, the Chair, suggested adding a sentence stating that the Commission’s goal is to align its work with the City of Asheville’s comprehensive plan and City Council priorities.

Kim Roney, the City Council liaison, provided information on upcoming public workshops regarding the restructuring proposal, scheduled for March 3, 7, 9, and 11, 2022. When asked for her personal opinion, Roney stated her goal was to support the Commission’s work and defer to their expertise, noting, "I'm happy to share my personal opinion at another time, but I think the goal for today has to be centering your work and your opinions on this." In closing remarks, Roney clarified that a plan presented at a previous public meeting was not a duplication of efforts but a demonstration of broad community support, emphasizing her role as a liaison between boards with similar goals.

Community Input

No public comments were received during the designated time.

Follow-ups

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:

  • The applicant for the 635 Patton Avenue project will work with City staff to revise the plan, specifically addressing tree species and their location relative to high-voltage lines, before returning to the Commission next month.
  • Chair Amy Smith will finalize the language for the updated Rules and Procedures document, with a draft to be sent to members for review within the next month and a final vote scheduled for the next meeting.
  • The Chair will schedule initial meetings for the new "Fee and Lou" and "Urban Forest Master Plan" working groups before the next Commission meeting.
  • Staff member Nancy Watford confirmed that the City is currently reviewing the revised Chapter 20 (Tree Protection Ordinance), with a meeting to review changes expected next week.
  • The Office of Data and Performance (ODAP) agreed to collaborate with the Commission on data needs for the Urban Forest Master Plan.
  • Sharon Summerall agreed to send specific examples of search difficulties in the Accella permitting system to Eric Jackson of ODAP for investigation.
  • Karen was asked to send the final motion document to Kim Roney.

Impact

This meeting addressed the immediate operational needs of the urban forest while formally responding to broader city governance changes. By tabling the 635 Patton Avenue project, the Commission ensured that safety concerns regarding high-voltage lines and tree durability are addressed before approval. The adoption of the resolution opposing the board restructuring signals the Commission’s stance on maintaining its specific expertise and volunteer capacity. Additionally, the collaboration with the Office of Data and Performance aims to align performance metrics with the Commission’s goals for the Urban Forest Master Plan, ensuring that data usage supports the city's urban forestry objectives.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches