Board of Adjustment
March 28, 2022 at 2:00 PM
- 1 h 18 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: March 28, 2022
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held a virtual quasi-judicial evidentiary hearing on March 28, 2022, to review a variance request from Benjamin and Tammy Mansell for their property at 46 Baird Street. The applicants sought three specific variances from the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding accessory structures on their approximately one-acre lot. The requests involved reducing a side setback, allowing a single structure to exceed the maximum footprint, and allowing the total footprint of all accessory structures to exceed the statutory limit.
Staff presented evidence indicating that the metal building in question was constructed without permits and currently violates setback and footprint limits. The Board discussed the legal standards required for granting variances, specifically the necessity for applicants to prove "unnecessary hardship" resulting from conditions peculiar to the property, rather than hardship caused by the applicant's own actions. Chair Paul Wilczynski noted that the board must base its decision on competent material and substantial evidence, and that a four-fifths vote of the Board is required to grant a variance.
The Board voted on each of the three requested variances individually, and all three motions to approve the variances failed. The first variance, which sought to reduce the side setback from six feet to four feet for the metal building, failed after at least four members voted "No." The second variance, requesting permission for a single accessory structure to exceed the 1,200-square-foot maximum footprint (currently 1,450 square feet), failed with a 3-2 vote. The third variance, requesting permission for the total accessory structure footprint to exceed the 1,600-square-foot maximum (currently calculated at 2,434 square feet), failed with a 1-4 vote.
During the hearing, a resident living on the western boundary of the property provided public comment, stating that the new metal building and its attached lean-to tower over their property, reflect light, and obstruct their view. The commenter expressed alarm at the unpermitted construction and noted that the structure reduces their property value and privacy. After the Board’s initial discussion, the same resident spoke again to emphasize that the lean-to is an independent structure that violates the setback and creates excess square footage, arguing that it would remain in violation even if the main garage were moved. The Chair and staff acknowledged the comments, with the City Attorney noting that the Board could impose conditions on any granted variance but emphasizing that the applicant must still prove the statutory standards.
Following the denials, staff confirmed that the applicant is required to bring the property into full compliance with the current ordinance. This includes removing the non-compliant structures or modifying them to meet setback and footprint limits. Staff member Ricky Hurley stated that if variances had been granted, they would work with the applicant to ensure the removal of structures the applicant volunteered to remove, such as a tent garage, front carport, and garden shed, potentially within a timeframe specified by the Board. However, because all variances were denied, the applicant must comply with the existing regulations. Applicant Benjamin Mansell stated, "I was wrong and guilty. That's why we're here," and expressed willingness to remove structures and make the property comply with setbacks as directed by the Board.
This decision impacts the Mansell property by mandating strict adherence to the City’s Unified Development Ordinance. The denial of the variances means the property cannot retain the current configuration of accessory structures, which exceed the allowed footprints and setbacks. The Board’s ruling reinforces that variances are not granted for structures built in violation of code or for hardships self-inflicted by the property owner. The applicant is now obligated to modify or remove structures to bring the lot into legal compliance with the City’s zoning requirements.
Meeting Video & Transcript