Board of Adjustment
November 28, 2022 at 2:00 PM
- 58 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: November 28, 2022
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened on November 28, 2022, to review two requests for variances related to property setbacks and driveway standards. The board considered applications for a non-conforming driveway and a front setback encroachment, ultimately denying one request and approving the other based on specific legal standards for variances.
Key Decisions The board voted to deny the driveway variance request submitted by Nicholas Cardillo. The vote was 3 ayes and 2 nays. Because the board determined that a variance requires a 4-1 vote to pass, the request was denied. The board cited the lack of a demonstrated "unnecessary hardship" as the primary reason, noting that the applicant’s arguments focused on aesthetics and convenience rather than specific site constraints.
In contrast, the board approved the front setback variance request for Sasha Madison, represented by Mike Sewell. The vote was 5 ayes and 0 nays. This approval allows an existing deck to encroach into a newly created 15-foot front setback. The variance was necessary because the closure of an adjacent "paper road" right-of-way—a road that exists on maps but has not been built—would reclassify the current side yard as a front yard, rendering the existing deck non-conforming.
Discussion Highlights During the discussion of the driveway variance, Chair Paul Wilczynski emphasized that the board must evaluate the request as if the work had not yet been done. He stated, "We have to look at it as though the applicant is coming in and saying, I want to do this. not that I already did... we are not to vote against it as punishment for there already having done it but we are not to vote for it because they've already gone through the time and expense to have done it."
Board member Suzanne Vernon Godsey expressed difficulty in finding a "site specific hardship" in the testimony, noting, "I have long had an issue with the 25 foot setback and I have long had an issue with parking in the setback... I'm having a hard time finding some type of site specific hardship related to this piece of property for this driveway." Board member Bill Newman agreed, stating, "I don't understand why they can't safely exit from a property that meets the standard... I also do not see the unnecessary hardship which is one of the requirements for granting a variance."
Regarding the front setback variance, staff member Chris Collins explained that the city cannot allow anything that increases the degree of nonconformity, but noted that the elimination of the paper road is of city benefit and provides clarity. Applicant representative Mike Sewell argued that the hardship was the cost-prohibitive nature of reconstructing the entire deck, stating, "Nothing really changes with construction. Everything stays the same except obviously the variance for the new frontage."
Community Input Public comment was received regarding the driveway variance. One public commenter, a neighbor, described the driveway as a "beautiful addition" and an "enhancement to the neighborhood," suggesting that the city’s liability concerns regarding non-standard materials were minor. Another public commenter, one of the property owners, stated that the owners were "willing to be responsible" for any damage to the driveway or city infrastructure and would sign a document acknowledging this responsibility.
In response, Chair Paul Wilczynski noted that while the board could consider the petition signed by approximately 30 people as a minor point, it should not be the major reason for voting in favor. Board member Suzanne Vernon Godsey reiterated that she could not find a "site specific hardship" in the testimony. No public comments were recorded for the front setback variance item.
Follow-ups A staff member indicated they would speak with the applicant for the driveway variance (Cardillo) outside the meeting to discuss what happens next after the denial. Additionally, a staff member noted that the city is currently working with emergency services and other departments to address the issue of unopened "paper road" rights-of-way, citing a statistic of 321 miles of such roads in the city.
Impact These decisions highlight the board's strict application of variance standards, specifically the requirement to demonstrate "unnecessary hardship" rather than mere convenience or aesthetic preference. The denial of the driveway variance underscores that existing improvements do not automatically qualify for variances if they do not meet current setback and width standards. The approval of the front setback variance reflects the board's recognition of administrative changes, such as the closure of paper roads, which can inadvertently make existing structures non-conforming.
Meeting Video & Transcript