City Council Retreat, Day 2 – March 18, 2022
March 18, 2022 at 8:52 AM
- 5 h 44 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Retreat, Day 2 Recap: March 18, 2022
The Asheville City Council convened for the second day of its annual retreat on March 18, 2022, focusing on the upcoming fiscal year’s budget, economic conditions, capital planning, and strategic priorities. The session began with a casual check-in where members shared their appreciation for the city’s community and natural beauty before moving into detailed discussions on financial forecasts and long-term planning.
Key Decisions and Strategic Priorities No formal votes were taken during this session. However, the Council reached a consensus to restructure its strategic priorities for the upcoming fiscal year. The Council decided to move "Compensation" and "ARPA Funds" from the active strategic priority list to the "operational" category, noting that Compensation is complete in its initial phase and ARPA funds are largely operationalized. The Council agreed to retain "Reparations" and "Reimagining Public Safety" as active strategic priorities. Additionally, the Council selected four new strategic priorities, resulting in a total of six for the coming year: Equitable, Affordable, and Stable Housing; Houselessness Strategies; Improving and Expanding Core Services; and Neighborhood Resilience.
Budget and Economic Context Staff presented an overview of the economic landscape, noting that while unemployment has recovered to pre-pandemic levels and wage growth is at historic highs, significant inflation in fuel and housing is limiting the city's ability to fund new services. The General Fund is expected to see revenue growth of $5.5 million to $6.5 million next year, driven by a 2% to 2.5% increase in property tax and a return to normal 5% to 8% growth in sales tax. Despite this growth, staff warned that rising personnel costs—due to compensation studies, reduced vacancies, and healthcare increases—along with higher operating costs for fuel and materials, will likely require revenue growth to maintain existing service levels. Staff recommended fee increases for the Sanitation, Stormwater, and Water funds to maintain service levels and credit ratings; these recommendations will be brought to the Finance and HR Committee for discussion.
Capital Planning and Infrastructure Capital Projects staff presented a plan for a comprehensive facility study, noting that more than 70% of city facilities are past their expected useful life. The study will assess facility conditions, space needs, and long-term funding strategies, incorporating sustainability goals and coordinating with the Transportation Development Authority (TDA) and Buncombe County. A key discussion point was pending state legislation that would allow the TDA to fund maintenance expenditures, not just new capital projects. The consultant contract for the study is expected to go to Council for approval in April or May, with fieldwork occurring over the summer to inform the 2024 Capital Improvement Plan. Additionally, the Water Resources Director presented a $20 million project to replace approximately 63,000 water meters with an Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) system, which aims to eliminate truck rolls for meter reading, enable real-time leak detection, and allow for monthly billing. The project is funded by short-term loans converted to long-term revenue bonds, and staff confirmed that meter readers will be retrained as technicians rather than losing their jobs.
Discussion Highlights Council members engaged in a "dreaming" exercise to identify ideal future goals before selecting the realistic strategic priorities listed above. During the discussion, Mayor Esther Manheimer highlighted the challenge of personnel capacity, stating, "One of our greatest challenges right now is in personnel... everybody's pretty well running as fast and as hard and as desperately as they can to accomplish what they are, and they don't have a lot of excess capacity if any, to take on a lot of new things." Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith clarified the distinction between strategic and operational items, noting, "When you're in the point of measuring, that is no longer a strategic priority. It's more operationalized." Council Member Antanette Mosley emphasized the need for an equity lens in housing discussions, stating, "If I were going to frame it without going into the granular, I would say not just housing, I would say equitable housing... coming up with imaginative ways to really understand the most vulnerable of the vulnerable." Council Member Sage Turner added, "If we don't do that with an equity lens, then we're gonna be increasing fees on people who can't afford it in the first place."
Follow-Ups Staff and Council agreed to several follow-up actions. Staff will provide updated year-to-date budget actuals and a document detailing how unbudgeted funds were spent at the April 12 work session. Staff will bring the Facility Study consultant contract to Council for approval in April or May and will bring fee increase recommendations for Sanitation, Stormwater, and Water to the Finance and HR Committee. Staff will develop departmental and individual project work plans aligned with the six strategic priorities to be presented at the beginning of the new fiscal year. Council members agreed to schedule a work session to review the proposed restructure of council committees and advisory boards to ensure alignment with the new priorities. Additionally, Council members agreed to hold a session with staff to discuss their reactions to the retreat outcomes.
Impact on Residents These decisions and discussions set the framework for how the city will allocate resources and prioritize projects in the coming year. The shift of certain initiatives to operational status allows the Council to focus its strategic energy on housing, houselessness, core services, and neighborhood resilience. The recommended fee increases and the AMI project will directly affect utility bills and service delivery, while the comprehensive facility study aims to address the aging infrastructure that impacts daily city operations.
Meeting Video & Transcript