Skip to main content
  • 4 h 26 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Retreat, Day 1 Recap: March 17, 2022

The Asheville City Council held the first day of its 2022 retreat on March 17, 2022, at the Harris-Cherokee Civic Center. The session focused on team building, reviewing internal working agreements, assessing staff morale, and clarifying the distinct roles of the Council and the City Manager. No formal votes or motions were taken during this portion of the retreat.

Key Discussions and Staff Morale Council members engaged in facilitated activities to rebuild cohesion after a period of virtual work. Council Member Sandra Kilgore noted that the retreat has fostered a new level of respect and calm among the group, while Council Member Gwen Wisler suggested that returning to in-person interaction is helping to rebuild unity. The Council reviewed their working agreements from the previous year, finding mixed performance: they rated themselves well on speaking up early and seeking different perspectives, but poorly on using pros/cons lists for decision-making. Members discussed that staff-provided pros/cons lists sometimes lack equity and sustainability impacts, with one member suggesting these factors be added to future staff reports.

A significant portion of the day was dedicated to a confidential survey of 17 department heads regarding staff morale. The most frequent response to how staff feel about their jobs was "overwhelming," attributed to staffing shortages and unrealistic expectations. Other common themes included feeling "exhausting" and "unvalued," with the latter linked to public criticism by Council members before consulting staff. Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed concern that these responses indicate a "perfect storm for mass exodus of people." In response, Council members acknowledged the strain on staff, with one member expressing regret for not expressing more appreciation in the past.

Strategic Priorities and Progress Staff provided updates on the Council’s four major priorities for the 2021–2022 term. For reparations for Black Asheville, $2.1 million has been set aside, and the formation of a 25-member commission is underway. Regarding employee compensation, the Council funded $7.9 million for a compensation study, resulting in a 2.5% increase for all city employees and significant increases for public safety staff. In reimagining public safety, funding was reallocated to move positions from the police department to social services and parks, and a consultant will be hired to develop a plan for unsheltered homelessness. For American Rescue Plan (ARP) funding, $8.3 million has been awarded, with an additional $17.9 million to be awarded. Staff also presented progress on eight strategic focus areas, noting that the primary holdup for the Transit Master Plan Phase One is a shortage of drivers, with the city currently having 54–56 drivers under contract but needing approximately 75 to implement new routes.

Community Input Before the meeting began, a resident outside the building expressed opposition to the criminalization of homelessness, stating, "And we are asking that you take care of your city, that you take care of your people. Stop criminalizing homelessness." Council members acknowledged the protest and asked the individual to move to the hallway to allow the meeting to proceed. No further public comment was recorded inside the meeting room.

Follow-ups and Next Steps Staff explicitly agreed to provide a briefing on the pros and cons of transitioning from small-group "check-ins" to full Council "work sessions" to help the Council make an informed decision on transparency and format. Staff also committed to working with department directors to establish a list of 29 top internal priorities for the end of the fiscal year and to use the Council’s priorities as "guardrails" for developing the annual operating budget and Capital Improvement Plan. The Council agreed to continue discussing the check-in vs. work session format on Day 2, where the afternoon session will focus on establishing strategic priorities for the upcoming fiscal year.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches