Human Relations Commission
March 17, 2022 at 5:29 PM
- 1 h 42 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: March 17, 2022
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville met on March 17, 2022, to address procedural updates, committee structures, and community concerns regarding housing and education. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates on the Reparations Project, and a review of proposed changes to the Commission’s Rules of Procedure. Additionally, the Commission received updates from its standing committees on Intergovernmental Relations, Community Engagement, Housing Issues, Examining Systems, and Improving HRCA.
The Commission voted to approve the minutes from the January 20, 2022, and February 17, 2022, meetings. In both instances, motions were made and seconded, followed by roll call votes in which all present commissioners voted "Yes," resulting in unanimous approval for both sets of minutes. No other formal votes were taken during the meeting.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to proposed changes to the HRCA Rules of Procedure. The legal representative explained that specific demographic quotas would be removed from membership requirements because quotas are not permitted under federal or state law for any type of selection process. Other proposed edits included reducing the number of commissioners from 15 to 11 and updating terminology for inclusivity, such as changing "Latinx" to "Latin/A/O/E" and adding "LGBTQIA+." No vote was taken on these changes; instead, the legal representative agreed to make the suggested edits and provide the revised document to staff for distribution before the next meeting, where it will be brought back for a vote.
Staff provided an update on the Reparations Project, noting that full approval has been received for 25 members. Staff member Brenda Mills stated that on April 12th, the City Council will need to appoint two alternates. Mills also agreed to check with the clerk’s office regarding the timeline for returning to in-person meetings and to keep the public advised on whether future reparations commission meetings will be in-person or virtual.
Regarding committee structures, the Commission discussed creating a specific focus on public housing. Staff suggested adding a subcommittee for public housing issues under the existing housing committee rather than creating a new top-level committee. The chair agreed to this structure. Additionally, staff agreed to share contact information between Commissioner Harrell and Commissioner Young to facilitate their collaboration on the "Examining Systems" committee. Commissioner Young also agreed to reach out to the public housing committee to coordinate support and potentially invite them to present at a future HRCA meeting.
Public comment was received regarding the proposed sanctuary camping policy and a student walkout at Asheville High School. Several public commenters urged the Commission to support the sanctuary camping proposal, arguing that sanctioned camps are more cost-effective than repeated sweeps and that the city is already spending money on policing and emergency care. One virtual participant specifically urged the Commission to "wholeheartedly support and recommend" the proposal rather than hiring an outside consultant. No members or staff responded directly to these comments during the public comment period. Another public commenter asked for support for a student walkout scheduled for the next day. Council Liaison Kim Rooney responded by explaining that the walkout was due to the removal of homeroom, which is the only time students can participate in clubs like the Black Student Union without needing after-school transportation.
The meeting concluded with a preview of upcoming agenda items, including equity and inclusion training, complaint processes, and a volunteer mentorship program. The Commission also noted that "Listening and the Training Seminars for City of Asheville and Public" were moved under Intergovernmental Relations, and "COVID-19 Outreach" was removed from the unfinished business list as that work was completed.
Meeting Video & Transcript